marriage, what if??? Options

[SkaironFrenzy]

if i there is homosexual marriages, then that wont be fair to the people who want to get married to their animals

[sadolakced acid]

gay marraige is currently illegal in some states. so yes, it's against the law.
so currently gays don't get to get married in those states.

my argument, if you will realize, was in response to your question why shouldn't a 5 year old and a 40 year old get married. this is why. because it is illegal.

however, in states where it is legal, then gays should get married.

if gays wish to get married in thier own states, they must try to get the ban repealed.

however marraige is a right reserved to the states. therefore the federal government cannot pass a law banning or allowing it, it must pass an amendment.

and you are completely right, except for this:

So according to you, gay marriage should not be legal, because it's against the law.

that is not according to me... notice i did not say that incess should not be legal because it's against the law. this is your own conclusion.

which i refute, in that if it were made legal it would not be against the law, and therefore should be made legal (? that's just inversing what you said. )

now if you had said gay marraige should not happen because it's illegal, then that would be what i'm saying.

now, i think if you wish to argue this, we should do so on the gay marraige board.