Twilight & Philosophy Options

[mipadi]

While persusing Amazon, I came across the book Twilight and Philosophy. As much as I can't stand Twilight, I'm actually in support of this book. I've ready a few other similar books (there are similar books for both Star Wars and The Matrix), and they tend to be a fun, interesting, if unorthodox way to relate philosophical concepts to mainstream movies. Anyone happen to check this out?

[creole]

According to Borders, this book got 1 star.

"First, I find it highly offensive when people write about topics they are not familiar with.

This author bases an entire chapter on Bella's vegetarianism because she ordered Mushroom Ravioli after Edward rescues her then takes her to dinner.

Read the book...it clearly states that Bella ordered the first thing she saw on the menu...Mushroom Ravioli...the book does not claim that Bella is a vegetarian...Katherine Hardwicke (director of Twilight) took that creative liberty while making the movie..{watch her own documentary..she admits it.}

Therefore, if a writer is going to analyze the philosophical impact of a fictional young adult series, that author should actually read the series first before putting his name on a book claiming to understand the underlying reasons for this series popularity.

Trying to attach Greek philosophies and Christian doctrine to a series that was only written because a woman named Stephenie Meyers woke up from a dream and began journaling the characters is absolute nonsense. Stephenie clearly states that she never intended to write a book, she doesn't even like the horror genre, never even watched 'vampire' movies....."I'm Mormon" she says. Stephenie had a dream one night, it impacted her that entire day so she wrote it out, 3 months later, she wrote a book......what's the big deal here, is the author--William Irwin---so desperate to be published that he can't take the time to know what he is actually writing about?

Again, if a writer is going to summarize a book series, said author should at least do more than watch the movie and read an unpublished portion of 'Midnight Sun' to address why this series has captured the hearts and minds of millions of girls and women world wide....."

Gender: Female
Age: 35-44
Occupation: Architecture / Engineering / Science
Favorite genre of music: Jazz
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.

Idk, is it really worth the $20?