Rehabilitation or Retribution, Our criminal justice system. Options

[MissHygienic]

Which one should we focus on more in our criminal justice system? Basically, which one would serve as a satisfactory/fitting punishment for prisoners?

[ersatz]

You guys keep saying it won't work here, but you haven't explained why it won't work here other than, "We are not Norway." So...?

And, if that argument is so sound, then why are we trying to make Iraq into a democratic state? Why do we think that sort of thing is an OK change, when, clearly, Iraq /= America, but we think that taking a look at our prison and healthcare systems is entirely too dramatic, because America /= Norway, Iceland, Sweden, France, England, Belgium, Ireland, Spain, Germany....

[kryogenix]

You guys keep saying it won't work here, but you haven't explained why it won't work here other than, "We are not Norway." So...?

http://www.createblog.com/forums/index.php...t&p=2848742

Read:

You're using the logic that since Norway + Five Star Hotel prison system = good prisoners, then America + Five Star Hotel prison system = good prisoners. The problem with that logic is that America != Norway, and that's EXACTLY why you can write it off as a system that will not work if implemented now.

Your recipe for success doesn't work if you're substituting the wrong ingredients in. There are plenty of reasons why America's prisons being different from Norway would mean that their system would not work here. Like I was alluding to with paperplane, you don't have racial diversity in the prisons in Norway, so there are no race wars there. You don't have an enormous population in Norway. You don't have the same income tax as in Norway. You're not going to be able to scale up huge programs like that to America-size without things becoming incredibly inefficient.

Why this is so hard to understand, I do not know.

And, if that argument is so sound, then why are we trying to make Iraq into a democratic state? Why do we think that sort of thing is an OK change, when, clearly, Iraq /= America, but we think that taking a look at our prison and healthcare systems is entirely too dramatic, because America /= Norway, Iceland, Sweden, France, England, Belgium, Ireland, Spain, Germany....

I don't think democracy works for everyone. Likewise, Norway's prison system will not work for everyone.

So there goes that argument. Nice try.