Smart section Options

[*Steven*]

I think we need a sub forum for things considered smart. I know it might not consist of the smartest responses, but it will be an area of intellectual stimulation. I derived this idea from Josh's and Nate's comments regarding trolling and lack of news-worthy topics. Nate made a news topic yesterday and I believe there has only been a few response (myself and JC, I believe, I could be missing some). Regardless, I believe that a sub forum for that kind of subject would be cool.

For instance, it could be something like interests named say, "Thoughtful Discussion" (with emphasis on thoughtful). It could consist of say:
News
Debate
Technology
School

[*Steven*]

I'm not saying I think the whole idea of a "smart section" is a bad thing, nor do I think it will necessarily segregate people more so than they already are. People will judge people no matter where they see them posting, and people will stick to their cliques because people tend to migrate towards people whom they have things in common with or share ideas. I think the "smart section" will attract people to give their input regarding news or debate or whathaveyou. I was saying that I didn't think that an application was necessarily a good thing as it restricts access. Also, I don't see people posting things in debate or news then never coming back. Typically, those people are seeking an argument or debate. Also, even if they don't come back, it only adds to the topic at hand and gives more to think about.

[Uronacid]

I'm not saying I think the whole idea of a "smart section" is a bad thing, nor do I think it will necessarily segregate people more so than they already are. People will judge people no matter where they see them posting, and people will stick to their cliques because people tend to migrate towards people whom they have things in common with or share ideas. I think the "smart section" will attract people to give their input regarding news or debate or whathaveyou. I was saying that I didn't think that an application was necessarily a good thing as it restricts access. Also, I don't see people posting things in debate or news then never coming back. Typically, those people are seeking an argument or debate. Also, even if they don't come back, it only adds to the topic at hand and gives more to think about.

So, you just want a smart section to say, "This section is for smart topics. Not for foolin, come in here if you want to have a good conversation. It's not for shits and giggles."

You don't care if everyone is allowed, you just want it labeled so people know what to expect?