Rules... what constitutes PG-13, I don't understand... Options

[*Uronacid*]

Alright, ever since I have been on create blog people have been posting away, cussing, and making sexual passes at eachother... talking about spiting and swallowing and showing off their tits... I don't want to see this change, in fact... I think it's very intresting, but I think it's rediculous when topics like this:

http://www.createblog.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=146208

:are closed, and are considered inapropriate. Topics like this, where someone is asking a question that if asked in a serious manner (which it was), and being a topic that does come up in a boys locker room, is deffinitly PG-13.

and topics like this:

http://www.createblog.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=113799

:are left open. Under-aged girls are posting pictures of their breasts on the internet while guys between the ages of 12-25 look and drool.

I mean, it just seems so rediculous. It pisses me off to see something so normal being discussed in a boy's locker room being discussed there, when admin's come along and close the topic... (I have nothing against the admin who did it)... Kathleen just jumps in there and posts about why the topic should be closed in big bold print. Why, is Kathleen jumping arounf in the boy's locker-room talking about why topics should be closed? I have no idea... why should girls have a say in what topics are inappropriate in the guys locker-room? Some topics that guys talk about are totally normal for them to talk about between each-other, and are deffinitly pg 13 if talked about in a serious manner... I don't see guys jumping from topic to topic in the girls locker room talking about how their topics should be closed... Look, personaly I think this:

http://www.createblog.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=143178
(btw, look what kathleen said in this topic)

isnt much different than this:

http://www.createblog.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=146208

yet she totally bashs ours, and our topic gets the close-out... I mean, cmon

how about this:

http://www.createblog.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=143392

when you suck a penis, do you spit out the spunk or do you swallow it? Is this pg-13.... get real, you guys are so unfair to the guys locker room...

I have been meaning to bring this up for a while.. I guess I just never did, becuase I felt that you guys would just start closes all the intresting sexual topics out there... being a teenager, sex is one of the most intresting things that there is, and I don't want to see this aspect of create blog get taken away... All i want is for people to treat the boy's lockeroom with the same respect as the girls locker room... I think it's rediculous, how we are literally treated differently....

[*Azarel*]

Okay, first of all, let's establish that this thread was not closed because it was inappropriate; it was closed because it is a duplicate topic. The second thing we should establish is that both the boys' locker and the girls' locker are lightly moderated, and thus littered with many (many) topics that should either be closed or merged due to its impropriety or duplicity. (Which is why that spit or swallow thread is still open.)

Kathleen's post was not about why the topic should be closed, but rather on the content of your specific post because it does not pertain to or contribute to the original topic. I'm not trying to side with Kathleen because she is my friend, and yes, the large font was unneccessary, but it seems more like you harbor a personal grudge (well, we all already know that) and are trying to shed bad light on Kathleen, so let's not make this thread a personal attack.

Another thing: nowhere does it state that girls are not allowed in the boys' locker and vice versa; if you think that they shouldn't be allowed to visit each other's lockers, than perhaps you should head over to Blogring, where doing so is prohibited. It's been long known that the girls of the site skew the statistics of all the polls in the guys' locker.

The sexy chest thread is not restricted to only females posting; after all, many guys do post their pecs/abs in the thread. However, I concede that you may be right on how appropriate it is.

Again, I'm restating that the masturbation topic was not closed because it was not PG-13, because a lot of your argument rests on the male masturbation topics being considered inappropriate and female masturbation topics appropriate.

Also, yes, there are topics in the lockers that may be pg-13 if discussed in a serious matter. However, most of cB is not mature enough to so, which is why said topics are closed.

[*Uronacid*]

Okay, first of all, let's establish that this thread was not closed because it was inappropriate; it was closed because it is a duplicate topic. The second thing we should establish is that both the boys' locker and the girls' locker are lightly moderated, and thus littered with many (many) topics that should either be closed or merged due to its impropriety or duplicity. (Which is why that spit or swallow thread is still open.)

Kathleen's post was not about why the topic should be closed, but rather on the content of your specific post because it does not pertain to or contribute to the original topic. I'm not trying to side with Kathleen because she is my friend, and yes, the large font was unneccessary, but it seems more like you harbor a personal grudge (well, we all already know that) and are trying to shed bad light on Kathleen, so let's not make this thread a personal attack.

Another thing: nowhere does it state that girls are not allowed in the boys' locker and vice versa; if you think that they shouldn't be allowed to visit each other's lockers, than perhaps you should head over to Blogring, where doing so is prohibited. It's been long known that the girls of the site skew the statistics of all the polls in the guys' locker.

The sexy chest thread is not restricted to only females posting; after all, many guys do post their pecs/abs in the thread. However, I concede that you may be right on how appropriate it is.

Again, I'm restating that the masturbation topic was not closed because it was not PG-13, because a lot of your argument rests on the male masturbation topics being considered inappropriate and female masturbation topics appropriate.

Also, yes, there are topics in the lockers that may be pg-13 if discussed in a serious matter. However, most of cB is not mature enough to so, which is why said topics are closed.

I guess I just don't like the fact that kathleen did it becuase she is a girl, I don't have a problem with the girls browsing the guys forums and posting, but I deffinitly don't see any other females doing that in the guys room. I feel like she consistantly rats people out. It's rediculous. Somtimes, the topics deserve to be close, but if a topic is going to be closed or ratted on in the guys locker room don't you think it should be a guy who should do it.
I see her breaking the PG-13 rule all the time, and I also see her post and have convo's in topics that have deffinilty been created before without saying a word. I guess she was jsut the final straw for me in the guys locker room. I see topics get closed all the time becuase girls seem to think they are inappropriate. If you are in the guys locker room, then you shouldn't be offened. I don't want girls to be unable to post, and i don't want girls to feel unwanted, but I don't think girls should be in there ratting us off for being inappropriate if they are reading things in the Boy's locker-room of their own free will. I have nothing against her personally. I'm sorry if this looks like a personal attack, but I do see her ratting people out in topics quite frequently...

Look, I don't want topics like this to be banned, and I think they make this site very unique. But, I hate seeing topics that aren't bad get closed especially when they don't need to be. The maturbation thread that was similiar was not the same, it didn't even have a poll.

[*Azarel*]

I guess I just don't like the fact that kathleen did it becuase she is a girl, I don't have a problem with the girls browsing the guys forums and posting, but I deffinitly don't see any other females doing that in the guys room. I feel like she consistantly rats people out. It's rediculous. Somtimes, the topics deserve to be close, but if a topic is going to be closed or ratted on in the guys locker room don't you think it should be a guy who should do it.

It shouldn't make a difference who reports what. There are plenty of other females browsing the boys' locker, and I myself have done the same thing with some topics, by PMing a mod. I highly doubt that you would be pissed off if Kathleen had PMed a mod so that you didn't know who reported the thread. Really now.

I see her breaking the PG-13 rule all the time, and I also see her post and have convo's in topics that have deffinilty been created before without saying a word. I guess she was jsut the final straw for me in the guys locker room. I see topics get closed all the time becuase girls seem to think they are inappropriate. If you are in the guys locker room, then you shouldn't be offened. I don't want girls to be unable to post, and i don't want girls to feel unwanted, but I don't think girls should be in there ratting us off for being inappropriate if they are reading things in the Boy's locker-room of their own free will. I have nothing against her personally. I'm sorry if this looks like a personal attack, but I do see her ratting people out in topics quite frequently...

Where have you seen that?

And if you "see topics get closed all the time because girls seem to think they are inappropriate," why did you say earlier that you "don't see any other females doing that in the guys room"? ...

Look, I don't want topics like this to be banned, and I think they make this site very unique. But, I hate seeing topics that aren't bad get closed especially when they don't need to be. The maturbation thread that was similiar was not the same, it didn't even have a poll.

Poll or no poll, the content was the same. If I were a mod, though, I personally would've merged the topics or split the polls and added them to the existing topics.