need some advice, two guys or no guys? Options

[fuzz4]

ok so theres these two guys i know. Josh and Will. They are both in one of my classes together. I knew Will last year and met Josh this year. Last year I could tell Will had a crush on me. Josh i like as a friend but could possibly consider having a relationship with. Will I would just prefer to be friends with. Will and Josh just met this year in the class that I am in.

My friend Samantha, who is also in my class with them, was sitting outside one day a couple weeks ago waiting for class. Will was out there and Josh came up to him and was all "ok ill come up with a few chords you can play for her and she'll be going to prom with you in no time" I overheard this part because i walked by them on the way into class. I was hoping they werent talking bout me because I would say no if he asked me to prom. I mean he's a nice enough guy and all but I would like to go with someone I actually like. Anyway Samantha told me a couple days ago that the conversation continued after what I had heard. Will then replies to Josh "Ya but you like her more than I do." Samantha thought they were talking about me because they dont hang out together other than this class and they both tend to flirt with me in class. I believed her and talked to my friend Kyle who is good friends with Josh. I told him about the incident and that i would rather go with Josh if he liked me.

The next day, yesterday, Kyle told me online that they werent talking about me. I felt so stupid and concieted! I just played it off going "whew! i dont need this much drama in my life anyway" and he laughed. A couple hours later I saw Samantha at a party I went to. I told her they werent talking about me and she said it sounded like a cover up.

So do you think it's a cover up or are they really talking about somebody else? Or how do i go about finding out if is was a cover up or not?