JACOB BLACK!, Cause he's cute and cuddly Options

[Comptine]

I noticed there's a fanclub for Edward but there isn't one for Jacob. I think that's highly unfair and decided to balance it out.

Character Biography

Full Name: Jacob Black
Status: Werewolf
Date of Birth: 1990
Originally from: Forks, WA
Hair color: Black (TW6)
Eye color: Brown (TW6)
Height: 6′5" (NM5)
Physical description: Long, glossy hair in a pony tail, beautiful skin, a hint of childish roundness to his chin (TW6) In his wolf form, Jacob’s coat is a rusty brown color. (NM10)
Occupation: Protect the LaPush area from Vampires
Family members: His mother, Sarah, died many years ago and he has twin older sisters, Rachel and Rebecca. (TW6)
Hobbies: Fixing up cars and motorcycles

Possible Choices for Jacob in Movie

Stephenie Meyer said that she can picture Tyler Posey as Twilight aged Jacob.



She also said that her favorite suggestion for an older Jacob is Steven Strait (!!!!!!! How can you not like him now with that picture in your head???)



I'll add more stuff but if there are any Jacob fans out there, make yourself known.

[cheerbee07]

haha, i love jacob.
even if he was quite a bit of a jerk in eclipse...

and i swear there's this guy i know that when i think of jacob, i picture him. his name is Jonny, he's native american, used to have long hair, and is MAJORLY tall.

[lojay]

There is something about Jacob that really bothers me. I just want to jump in the book and slap him. Haha. Personally I feel he is selfish to always want Bella and not consider her feelings toward Edward or towards affecting anything but his own wellbeing. But hey, that's just me.

As for Jacob's appearance/character, I can sooo see Tyler Posey as Jacob. I find Steven Strait too attractive for the part... Or maybe just too 'normal.' Tyler Posey seems so much more warm and native. Just my opinion though.

[KayleighKins]

I'm so joining I'm so joining I'm so joining! <3 <3

Tyler Posey looks a bit Asian in the eyes, and the other one doesn't have that sexy skin color. But, between them, Tyler Posey ftw :D

[jue]

I can kind of see Steven Strait as Jacob Black. Every time I see a picture of Steven Srait, I always picture him in Sky High.

[tokyo-rose]

I'll joinnn. :D

You misspelled the author's name. o.- It's Stephenie with an "E" and there's no "S" at the end of her name.

I think both Tyler and Steven would make good Jacobs. I can't decide. Maybe if I saw more pictures of them then I could. xD

[*Michelle*]

HIGHLY UNFAIR?!?!?!

There should be a war between the two groups. I hate Jacob Black. He's disgusting, rude, and selfish. Hmph.

[lovefooled]

HIGHLY UNFAIR?!?!?!

There should be a war between the two groups. I hate Jacob Black. He's disgusting, rude, and selfish. Hmph.

I agree completely.

[breakingdawn]

Jakey!

[KayleighKins]

I agree completely.

It's a good thing you can leave then :D

[tokyo-rose]

Seriously now. The Jake fans don't bash Edward in the Edward thread, after all.

[*Michelle*]

Hee hee I was joking. But I still think we should have a war.

[Comptine]

But Edward is always cold. I hate being cold. I want to snuggle up to something nice and warm.

And besides, Steven Strait is permanently embedded into my mind as Jacob. And Steven/Jacob is hot.

And, whoops, Stephenie Meyer. Haha. I wasn't paying attention.

[breakingdawn]

Hee hee I was joking. But I still think we should have a war.

If we're going to have a war we should have a Team Switzerland, for those of us who love both our werewolves and vampires dearly.

[KayleighKins]

^ You could have one. But that's just indecisive. x3

But Edward is always cold. I hate being cold. I want to snuggle up to something nice and warm.

God yes! Plus Jacob doesn't make me wanna barf a little every time he talks--or when he prompts Bella to talk.

Jacob ftw!

[*Michelle*]

Hey everyone!

We want to do a reading circle... basically, we're gonna re-read all the books again and discuss them. ^_^

We can talk about our new findings or whatever in a month or so. Happy reading! :D

[EmoEyelinerx]

Edwards way better

Jacobs ugly, rude and selfish.

Edward on the other hand..dont get me started.

Ok, im done being mean now..

[technicolour]

Edwards way better

x17861786127864217861278654587342761278315786142578642



But Steven Strait is freaking fwwwinnnneeeee with me. Mmmhmm!

[EmoEyelinerx]

x17861786127864217861278654587342761278315786142578642

*High Five*

[breakingdawn]

Edwards way better

Jacobs attractive, courteous and unselfish.

Edward on the other hand..dont get me started.

Ok, im done being mean now..

Okay, I fixed it for you.

[EmoEyelinerx]

Okay, I fixed it for you.

Hey no way thats not what I said >.<

[breakingdawn]

Hey no way thats not what I said >.<

[KayleighKins]

Edwards way better

No.


Edward is bossy, controlling and emo.

[xBUTTMUNCHx]

I LOVE MY VAMPIRES!

but, Jake..is very interesting...teehee

[EmoEyelinerx]

No.
Edward is bossy, controlling and emo.

No huh hes not. A vampire is not emo. I bet you dont even know what emo is.

[tokyo-rose]

I don't think Edward is emo, and I don't like that word anyway. It's not possible for a person to be a kind of music. A better word would be "depressed," which I don't think he is.

[Comptine]

^He's depressing.

Like, if he was human, he would've slit his wrists.

[*Michelle*]

I don't know... Edward may be slightly emo, but I don't date rapists!

[Comptine]

He kissed her! He was a jerk about it, but it was just a kiss.

Right? I didn't finish Eclipse yet.

[*Michelle*]

He kissed her! He was a jerk about it, but it was just a kiss.

Right? I didn't finish Eclipse yet.

*shrug* No spoilers revealed from me! Get outta these threads and finish the book! haha

[KayleighKins]

He kissed her! He was a jerk about it, but it was just a kiss.

Right? I didn't finish Eclipse yet.

Yeah, Jacob would never rape anyone. He kissed her, and it was wrong, but he was right, in the end.

I bet you dont even know what emo is.

Oh please teach me your higher knowledge. [/sarcasm]

I don't give a shit what emo to you is. To the rest of us it's a completely understandable sentence.

I also don't know why there are a bunch of Edward fans in this post acting as if it's very existence is an insult to who they are. How about you all stop taking it personally and gets over the fact that some people don't like your favorite?

GTFO!

^He's depressing.

Like, if he was human, he would've slit his wrists.

Lol, true that. But in the book it's like, "Oh man, I would have slit my wrists, but then I was like OMGBBQ, it's Bella! So now I won't slit my wrists. Now I'll just be a big baby who controls your life."

I could never in a million years deal with some boy who thinks he can control me like Edward does to Bella. It actually disgusts me. She doesn't like it either, but she's forced to be ok with it. And the fact that she loves him so much makes her get over it?

What the f**k?

She's giving up and changing her entire life to be with this kid. This kid who hardly even lets her be herself!

[tokyo-rose]

He kissed her! He was a jerk about it, but it was just a kiss.

Right? I didn't finish Eclipse yet.

Yep. Agreed that Jake would never rape anyone.

I also don't know why there are a bunch of Edward fans in this post acting as if it's very existence is an insult to who they are. How about you all stop taking it personally and gets over the fact that some people don't like your favorite?

[lojay]

Lol, true that. But in the book it's like, "Oh man, I would have slit my wrists, but then I was like OMGBBQ, it's Bella! So now I won't slit my wrists. Now I'll just be a big baby who controls your life."

I could never in a million years deal with some boy who thinks he can control me like Edward does to Bella. It actually disgusts me. She doesn't like it either, but she's forced to be ok with it. And the fact that she loves him so much makes her get over it?

What the f**k?

She's giving up and changing her entire life to be with this kid. This kid who hardly even lets her be herself!

I see your point, but at the same time, I think Edward is a lot more open to what Bella wants than Jacob. I mean, Edward even said that if she wanted to be with Jacob, so be it [even though he would be upset, but I mean, come on, anyone would be in that position if they lost someone they love]. However, Jacob isn't really looking out for Bella's feelings; he is just going off kissing her and being all "You should be with me I def like you better!" And all that "screw Edward" bull. But heyy, that's just what I think. Not bashing Jacob... I just thought that it was strange that you mentioned that Edward controls Bella when he allows her the biggest option of all; her heart. I feel as though Jacob is more controling or at least tries to be.

[sweetdreamer298]

I do perfer Jacob over Edward only because there's a less risk of Bella DYING if he's with her. Plus he's warm and...shirtless most of the time >///< But I'd rather her be with Edward mostly because I don't want him trying to commit suicide again.

[Larentia]

I'm pro-Edward, but I can see the advantages of Jacob.
Such a difficult choice.

[breakingdawn]

I'm pro-Edward, but I can see the advantages of Jacob.
Such a difficult choice.

YOU SHOULD JOIN TEAM SWITZERLAND!

hahaha, sorry. We just need more members!

[KayleighKins]

I see your point, but at the same time, I think Edward is a lot more open to what Bella wants than Jacob. I mean, Edward even said that if she wanted to be with Jacob, so be it [even though he would be upset, but I mean, come on, anyone would be in that position if they lost someone they love]. However, Jacob isn't really looking out for Bella's feelings; he is just going off kissing her and being all "You should be with me I def like you better!" And all that "screw Edward" bull. But heyy, that's just what I think. Not bashing Jacob... I just thought that it was strange that you mentioned that Edward controls Bella when he allows her the biggest option of all; her heart. I feel as though Jacob is more controling or at least tries to be.

He doesn't have a choice when it comes to her heart. If her heart changed to Jacob, Edward wouldn't be able to live with her always loving someone else. He gives her the choice because he realizes that he doesn't have one himself.

Jacob already knew her heart. Jacob knew Bella loved both he and Edward, it's proven. He didn't know how to show Bella, he was desperate for her to know and make her choice so he wouldn't have to go through life wondering, go through life loving someone who refused to believe it herself.

He bad talked Edward because they were rivals. You have to be kidding yourself if Edward wasn't always calling Jacob a dog, or telling Bella she smelled like one. They both couldn't stand the other because they had to share the woman they loved.

Edward isn't some sort of angle from heaven with a huge and good heart while Jacob is this horrible boy trying to steal his girl. Edward would have you believe that, but that isn't true.

Imagine finding your soul mate, knowing she is your soul mate, knowing you could have had a life together, and your mortal enemy has her. Kisses her, god knows what with her...if you had a chance to receive her love, would you try?

Jacob cares too much for her feelings.

And she gives up her entire joyful life with him--including children and her family--to be with the vampire. That is how Jacob and I both see it. It's a choice that is totally alien to me. She gives up her security for an overwhelming and all consuming need.

I can't see that being a healthy sort of love. There are things that come with love, and she's given up all of them. It makes me so angry and sad and fskdjfsd. You don't give up true love! You don't give up security and family!

Ugh.

[*Moderator*]

I've yet to read the books but Edward does have a cute face. I gotta read the books to see who all these people are, but it'd be cool if Steven Strait played in it.

[lojay]

Edward isn't some sort of angle from heaven with a huge and good heart while Jacob is this horrible boy trying to steal his girl. Edward would have you believe that, but that isn't true.

Edward wouldn't have me believe anything he is a character in a book. lol.

Anyway, I really could care less what happens with Jacob. I mean, I prefer Bella being with Edward, but I understand she cares about Jacob and that Jacob is there for her and such. However, I just feel like she made her decision about Edward, and that's final. Even if she has some love for Jacob, it is clear that it doesn't compare to the compassion towards Edward.

I think you are getting yourself a little too worked up over characters in a book and proving to me that Jacob is a better match for Bella, lol. What does my opinion matter, anyway? Haha. I was just stating my views.

[breakingdawn]

He doesn't have a choice when it comes to her heart. If her heart changed to Jacob, Edward wouldn't be able to live with her always loving someone else. He gives her the choice because he realizes that he doesn't have one himself.

Jacob already knew her heart. Jacob knew Bella loved both he and Edward, it's proven. He didn't know how to show Bella, he was desperate for her to know and make her choice so he wouldn't have to go through life wondering, go through life loving someone who refused to believe it herself.

He bad talked Edward because they were rivals. You have to be kidding yourself if Edward wasn't always calling Jacob a dog, or telling Bella she smelled like one. They both couldn't stand the other because they had to share the woman they loved.

Edward isn't some sort of angle from heaven with a huge and good heart while Jacob is this horrible boy trying to steal his girl. Edward would have you believe that, but that isn't true.

Imagine finding your soul mate, knowing she is your soul mate, knowing you could have had a life together, and your mortal enemy has her. Kisses her, god knows what with her...if you had a chance to receive her love, would you try?

Jacob cares too much for her feelings.

And she gives up her entire joyful life with him--including children and her family--to be with the vampire. That is how Jacob and I both see it. It's a choice that is totally alien to me. She gives up her security for an overwhelming and all consuming need.

I can't see that being a healthy sort of love. There are things that come with love, and she's given up all of them. It makes me so angry and sad and fskdjfsd. You don't give up true love! You don't give up security and family!

Ugh.

If they're soul mates, why hasn't Jake imprinted on her?

[KayleighKins]

If they're soul mates, why hasn't Jake imprinted on her?

It says in the book that they are soul mates o.O I promise, I didn't just make shit up there.

And elbaliava I'm not getting worked up, or trying to prove to you why I should be right and blada blada, I'm just trying to get you to see my point.









At the very least, at least I'm not in your post bashing your mans without anything to help back myself up.

[lojay]

It says in the book that they are soul mates o.O I promise, I didn't just make shit up there.

And elbaliava I'm not getting worked up, or trying to prove to you why I should be right and blada blada, I'm just trying to get you to see my point.
At the very least, at least I'm not in your post bashing your mans without anything to help back myself up.

Haha. Alright. I saw your point. I just disagree. :]
And why do I need to back myself up if it's just an opinion I am making? I wasn't stating a fact nor a point, I was just speaking my mind.

[KayleighKins]

^ Because stating an opinion without proof to back it up in a forum setting is called spam.

[breakingdawn]

^ Because stating an opinion without proof to back it up in a forum setting is called spam.

I wouldn't go so far as to calling it spam...

[omgomgKATHY]

Steven Strait is the PERFECT Jacob.

If Jacob and Edward were somehow morphed...mmm

[breakingdawn]

Steven Strait is the PERFECT Jacob.

If Jacob and Edward were somehow morphed...mmm

[KayleighKins]

I wouldn't go so far as to calling it spam...

lol, it was a joke.

[lojay]

I wouldn't go so far as to calling it spam...

Yeah, neither would I.

lol, it was a joke.

Hahaha. right. So since when do you need proof for an opinion? It's an opinion, not a debate, haha. And stating an opinion/fact/etc in a post is kind of the idea of a reply. If I was completely off topic, now that would be spam.

I'm pretty much done discussing this, it's starting to get stupid. Apparently we have complete different viewpoints

[KayleighKins]

^ IT. WAS. A. JOKE.

If you don't get it. Get over it. I shouldn't have to add an "LOL JK JK JK" just so you don't jump down my throat.












LOL JK.

[sweetdreamer298]

*cough* Ummm....back to the point....

I don't think Jacob imprinted on her, he just really loves her. Where did it say they were soulmates. I honestly don't remember that.

[breakingdawn]

*cough* Ummm....back to the point....

I don't think Jacob imprinted on her, he just really loves her. Where did it say they were soulmates. I honestly don't remember that.

It does say it somewhere...but I don't understand how they can honestly think that even though Jacob hadn't imprinted on her. Doesn't he get that eventually some superhottie is going to walk in and he's gonna imprint on her and Bella's gonna be left in the dust? He's being selfish.

[megnast]

i LOVE jacob! honestly, it's edward that annoys me sometimes. he's almost too perfect to be desirable. not to say i'm not totally in love with him - I AM. i just think jacob gives bella more freedom and he doesn't baby her. i suppose edward babies her because he's seen such horrible things. jacob annoys me sometimes as well though.

favourite part: when jacob is keeping bella warm in the tent. poor edward.

but yeah, i love jacob and edward. :)


i wish bella would just take one moment to spaz out on edward. he really is controlling her life and he knows it. it makes me sad that bella is so transfixed with him. i think i'd much rather see her with jacob than with edward. or both! woo!

[breakingdawn]

but yeah, i love jacob and edward. :)

JOIN TEAM SWITZERLAND!

[Smarmosaur]

jacob's a little bit of a bitch;
but he's got good intentions.
and sorry, edward's always going to be WAY above jacob in my books. :]

[breakingdawn]

jacob's a little bit of a bitch;
but he's got good intentions.
and sorry, edward's always going to be WAY above jacob in my books. :]

That's all that counts though, right?

[livwho]

PERSONALLY, I love them both. But Jacob is more type, while Edward is so... there. All the time. Almost stalker-esque. I think I've been converted from hardcore Edward fan into Jacob lover extraordinaire.

You're right; Jake was a jerk in Eclipse. The epilogue made me fairly upset though. The way Leah wouldn't leave him alone. If I wanted to hit anyone the entire book, its her.

To be honest, I will be a bit upset if Bella ends up with Jake; Just because Edward and her are so meant to be together, while she and Jacob don't really "mesh". Ya know?

[Leosageheart]

I've always rooted for Edward, but Jacob has his moments as well.

Sun Lament

A total Team Jake song. It made me see Jacob's side. Even though in the end I'll always be rooting for Edward.

[tokyo-rose]

I really like Mitch Hensen for making Twilight-based music. ^_^ I haven't listened to "Sun's Lament" yet, though.

[tokyo-rose]

Bumppp.

I'm rereading Eclipse now. Gah, Jake.

[livwho]

Jake ftw. He is cute and cuddly. And warm. :cuddles:

[JokeInsideJoke]

me and my friend (who is currently sitting next to me) hate jacob.
no offence
i hate him for making bella love him
only vampires can love you forever.......

[tokyo-rose]

That's nice, but there is no bashing of Jake in this thread or of Edward in Edward's thread. (:

[RealTalk]

PERSONALLY, I love them both. But Jacob is more type, while Edward is so... there. All the time. Almost stalker-esque. I think I've been converted from hardcore Edward fan into Jacob lover extraordinaire.

You're right; Jake was a jerk in Eclipse. The epilogue made me fairly upset though. The way Leah wouldn't leave him alone. If I wanted to hit anyone the entire book, its her.

To be honest, I will be a bit upset if Bella ends up with Jake; Just because Edward and her are so meant to be together, while she and Jacob don't really "mesh". Ya know?

I totally agree.

I don't know. I seriously have a problem with the fact that Edward is cold (physically) all the time.

[Senta]

I love Edward, but I also love Jake. [:
But talking couple-wise; I think Edward is better for Bella. :D
--Just because Edward is..Edward :D
Other than that, hey, I`d hit it.

[ehsgee]

i started liking jacob in eclipse.xD

[ViolentAbandon]

Yeah, Jacob would never rape anyone. He kissed her, and it was wrong, but he was right, in the end.
Oh please teach me your higher knowledge. [/sarcasm]

I don't give a shit what emo to you is. To the rest of us it's a completely understandable sentence.

I also don't know why there are a bunch of Edward fans in this post acting as if it's very existence is an insult to who they are. How about you all stop taking it personally and gets over the fact that some people don't like your favorite?

GTFO!
Lol, true that. But in the book it's like, "Oh man, I would have slit my wrists, but then I was like OMGBBQ, it's Bella! So now I won't slit my wrists. Now I'll just be a big baby who controls your life."

I could never in a million years deal with some boy who thinks he can control me like Edward does to Bella. It actually disgusts me. She doesn't like it either, but she's forced to be ok with it. And the fact that she loves him so much makes her get over it?

What the f**k?

She's giving up and changing her entire life to be with this kid. This kid who hardly even lets her be herself!

Hey dude i seriously dont think you would be any different in the same situation, if you wanted someone so much you would be what ever they want, do what makes them happy, but also in a way that makes you both happy.
I dont think you can call Edward "emo" because he wasnt posing to die he was actually gonna kill him self. To him his life was meaningless with out Bella he couldnt just go back to how he used to be, didnt you read how hard it was for him to stay away from Bella when he left her for her own good.
He would be able to do anything, be with anyone but it just wouldnt be the same to him... and if you dont get that your simply a dumbshit that has no idea on love but i guess i dont know much more than you do.

Jacob is pretty cool though, a good person and goes after what he wants, (even with the forced kiss in mind which btw i hated but he was right) in the end he only got half way there... poor thing..

[ViolentAbandon]

JOIN TEAM SWITZERLAND!

LMAO your obsessed with Team Switzerland! I love it hahaha i wanna join, both Edward and Jacob have problems but i cant help but love them both, a combination of the two would be like Switzerland for me

[ViolentAbandon]

I love Edward, but I also love Jake. [:
But talking couple-wise; I think Edward is better for Bella. :D
--Just because Edward is..Edward :D
Other than that, hey, I`d hit it.

i agree but im still rooting for team switzerland coz its awesome!

[lovefooled]

Jacob in the movie.

[Comptine]

HOT FREAKIN' DAMN. :drool: He's got an 8 pack. But he looks mad young.

[monstrum]

How come no one's posting anything new here : (? Aww. There should be more Jacob Black lovers. They don't do him justice enough.

[honishihaka]

jacob black is totally eye candy. he just has that anger problem and after seeing what happened with emily sam and leah, i can see why she would chose to be with edward.

still, jacob black... mmmm. the whole warm, big muscles and bad boy attitude makes him the perfect fixation for anyone. too bad edward got there first. do you think she would have gone for jacob if he got there first?

[tokyo-rose]

still, jacob black... mmmm. the whole warm, big muscles and bad boy attitude makes him the perfect fixation for anyone. too bad edward got there first. do you think she would have gone for jacob if he got there first?

I think she would have gone for him if she had never met Edward. As long as Edward is in the picture/a part of Bella's life in some way, Bella would have gone for him no matter who she had met first.

[technicolour]

click to enlarge

He's perfect for Jacob. And I love Jacob. He almost seems like one of the most practical and sensible characters. Plus, he isn't annoying in the book!

[tokyo-rose]

It's kind of annoying how he kisses Bella against her will, but that's the only objection I have to his behavior.

[JokeInsideJoke]

jacob's a little bit of a bitch;
but he's got good intentions.
and sorry, edward's always going to be WAY above jacob in my books. :]

yeah, jacob is nowhere NEAR edward !

[monstrum]

I thought the whole point of having a Jacob thread was for Jacob fans, and I really like Jacob : ).

[tokyo-rose]

Haha, I agree. Stop saying Edward > Jacob in this thread; you can do that in the Edward thread! :P

Soo...I should really finish rereading Eclipse since I started that over Christmas break. >>;

[superstitious]

While my heart is eternally with Edward, I adore Jacob as well. It's hard not to like Jacob. He's the best friend anyone in their right mind would want.

[SiobhanG]

i [heart] BOTH Edward and Jacob! how could you not??? Bella is the one who needs to have a good amount of hate mail ! She ruined BOTH their lives... well not ruined, but made it hard for them! they're both perfect!

[tokyo-rose]

While my heart is eternally with Edward, I adore Jacob as well. It's hard not to like Jacob. He's the best friend anyone in their right mind would want.

I wholeheartedly agree. Bella would be hard-pressed to find anyone else as loyal as Jake is.

[Stephire]

^Well, unless Jacob imprints on some unsuspecting chick.
Which I hope never happens...I also hope she can't go trhough with being a vampire and she runs off to live with Jacob forever.

Edward is amazing, but Jacob is that plus more.

[superstitious]

I still think that regardless, Bella and Jake will always be the best of friends, even if from a distance. The thing is, Jake is just as risky, if not riskier for Bella than Edward is because he can imprint. Remember Sam and Emily? How much of a heart breaker would it be for Bella to be the "Leah"?

[Comptine]

But Sam and Emily... that's true love, right there. And they know it. Anyone would be jealous, regardless of whether they got imprint-left for.

Spoiler:
How crazy is it that Leah can change now and everyone can know her thoughts? That must be awkward.

Leah (thinking): Stupid bastard.
Sam (thinking): I can hear you.
Leah (thinking): I know.

[Luna5]

Who is this dude?

[Comptine]

... If you read the series, you would definitely know.

If you didn't, then it doesn't really matter.

I still haven't finished Eclipse.

edit:

Does anybody want to contribute icons/siggies/etc for Jacob? Both Taylor Lautner and Steve Strait don't have an abundance of photos to work with. I would like more Jacob love around this forum.

[klik89]

Removed.

Reason for edit: Image removed. - Cristy

[sweetest-emotion]

i almost wanted to skip over the professing of love parts in eclipse. it was excruciating to read it!
but i can definitely sympthasize with the two of them. i kinda have that dilemma right now with my bf and my best guy friend. i love my boyfriend but my best guy friend just confessed his love for me. unlike bella, i had feelings for my guy friend before i met my boyfriend. CRAZY.
i still don't know which one is my edward though... but i know one or the other will be hurt.

[Stephire]

^That sucks.

Who else thinks it would be awesome if Jacob murders Edward at the wedding?
Also, how heartbreaking for Jacob to know that she checks up on him but also know she's still getting married. Maybe Seth should try to repress his thoughts, or not phase. Poor Jacob being stuck in "I love you, just not enough" hell.
I'm glad the first chapter of breaking dawn talks about him, though.
I was afraid Stephenie Meyer might ditch his character because of the whole last line of Eclipse.

[tokyo-rose]

Who else thinks it would be awesome if Jacob murders Edward at the wedding?
Also, how heartbreaking for Jacob to know that she checks up on him but also know she's still getting married. Maybe Seth should try to repress his thoughts, or not phase. Poor Jacob being stuck in "I love you, just not enough" hell.
I'm glad the first chapter of breaking dawn talks about him, though.
I was afraid Stephenie Meyer might ditch his character because of the whole last line of Eclipse.

Haha, I wouldn't want that. I like both guys, I just favor Jake a bit more.

That would never happen. Breaking Dawn/the rest of the series would be so incomplete if Meyer stopped talking about Jake.

Do you guys think he'll imprint in BD? I really want him to, but I don't think he will. I get the feeling Jake will get the short end of the stick no matter what, unless Meyer can come up with a happy ending for him without sounding cheesy.

[Keldee303]

I'm gonna start with, I love both Jake and Edward. I'm all for the very tall, warm, tan guy with the sunny disposition though.
People here are hating on him saying that he's selfish to do what he does in Eclipse, but I think that if you were 16 or 17 (however old he is in the book at that point) you probably would react the same to keep the person that you'd attached yourself to so deeply. I would have said to hell with Edward...I love this person and I want them.

Although...you're right about him imprinting on someone else and leaving Bella out in the cold. That would suck a lot. I think he was lying about imprinting on her though. She seems just as attached to Jacob as he is to her, but she's like crazy in love with Edward so in the end...or what has been the end so far, Edward seems to have won.

The Edward/Jacob fight has been going on in my apartment since I forced my roommate to sit down and read the books, which she did in two days. Of course when she decided that she didn't like Jacob she skimmed over most of New Moon and parts of Eclipse...which pissed me off, but that's nothing new. She always calls me the Dog-Lover and is so damn mean about it, but I point back at her and call her the Undead-Lover...and she rolls her eyes. Its a battle, I tell you. I'm for Edward with Bella though...I'll gladly take Jacob if she doesn't want him.

:oD

[shoryuken]

Removed.

HAHAHAHAH.. ... NUB..

[Switzerland101]

It's like an argument at my house, too.... Most of my friends (except for one who LOVES Jacob) all LOVE Edward. So, I used to be a: "Go Edward! All the way!" fan but now I'm like: "I don't know... do I like Edward more? Or do I like Jake more?" I started changing sides during Eclipse when Jake started telling Bella that he loved her OVER AND OVER again... So... I'm confused ! I want Bella to end up with Edward though... MY happy story for Breaking Dawn is if:
1)Edward and Bella get married
2)Edward tries to "do" Bella (lol!)
3)Edward changes Bella
4)Jacob imprints on someone besides Bella
and
4)They all live happily ever after
THE END!
But I know that probably won't happen

[Keldee303]

Like I said, I want Bella with Edward. No doubt. And I have nothing against Edward at all....


...I just love this waaaay more.




Yes, I made this and yes, if you want the wallpaper size version just let me know.
Steven Strait as Jacob all the way...oh yeah.

[MorphineMayhem]

Blah, I feel like I'm in bellas situation, I'm completely in LOVE with edward, but then theres a spot for jacob also.

[IzzyGrace]

Ahaha, other way around for me :)
I just love Jacob.

My best friend saw Taylor Lautner in a tournament
*.* I. Love. Him.

^Well, unless Jacob imprints on some unsuspecting chick.
Which I hope never happens...I also hope she can't go trhough with being a vampire and she runs off to live with Jacob forever.

Edward is amazing, but Jacob is that plus more.

I disagree. I have nothing against Jake and Bella, I just don't think she deserves him after everything that she's done.

[tokyo-rose]

My best friend saw Taylor Lautner in a tournament
*.* I. Love. Him.

O_O Lucky girl! Did she get to talk to him or anything? What was the tourney for?

[pollypocky]

I disagree. I have nothing against Jake and Bella, I just don't think she deserves him after everything that she's done.

I totally agree with that.
Everything that she's made Jake go through
made me hate her soooo much.
Like, how she'd use him and urgh!
It just really made me mad.

And what was with all the Jake haters?
I can't see why people would do that.
Stupid. XD

[Stephire]

Even though she did all that, I still think Jake would be happiest with her by his side.

This love triangle stuff is always a very good story, but by the end I end up hating one guy or the other.
Every time I re-read New Moon I hate Edward more and more and like Jacob more and more.
They're soulmates damnit!
&Edward is totally gay if he didn't want to do her. I'm spreading that propaganda everywhere. EDWARD IS GAY. Why has he never liked anyone else before? GAY. He got hit on by Tanya and Rosalie and turned them down. GAY. And I repeat again, Bella threw herself at him and he stopped her. GAY. It's like that Katy Perry song: He's so gay and he doesn't even like boys.
Screw Edward and all his gayness. Jacob is a man among men.
Jacob>Edward, The End.

[tokyo-rose]

He's so gay and he doesn't even like boys.

That is contradictory.