Amy Lee v. Cristina Scabbia Options

[*Kathleen*]

So my boyfriend and I were arguing over this the other day. He thinks it's Amy Lee (of Evanescence) - I think it's Cristina Scabbia (of Lacuna Coil). I suppose you can Google them for pictures because I'm too lazy to host them myself, but chyeah.

[[Scr3amin][Horro...]

Amy Lee
Crz I dunno who Cristina Scabbia is
N I am 2 lazy 2 google it

[inthemudhole]

CRISTINA SCABBIA!

Ohh, man.
I think she is more talented, more unique, and better-looking.
She's my female idol.

--

Cristina





--

Amy





--

The pictures of Amy aren't the best because I was trying to hurry.
I already have Cristina pictures bookmarked and saved, so yeah. ;x

[Looow]

Amy Lee.

[sharerol]

Based on looks, I would say - Amy Lee < Cristina Scabbia.
But talent-wise, I would say - Amy Lee > Cristina Scabbia.

And how funny. When I went to look up pictures of Cristina, I found a few Amy Lee pictures.

[parallel]

I voted for Amy Lee because I don't know who the hell Cristina Scabbia is.

[*anubis*]

I voted for Amy Lee because I don't know who the hell Cristina Scabbia is.

ditto.

[save_the_cows]

Both good, but i think lacuna coil is better

[*mzkandi*]

I choose Amy Lee.

[1--GIRL]

i have no idea who Cristina Scabbia is, i pick amy lee.

[*Azarel*]

Cristina Scabbia is definitely more attractive, but Amy Lee's voice has more edge. But that's me of course. Voted Scabbia. +1 for Kathleen.

[racoons > you]

have to say, cristina is better looking....

[angel-roh]

Amy Lee is better looking and a better vocalist =]

[technicolour]

Amy Lee. Hands down. She looks good in the 'Everybody's Fool' vid, and since I have no clue who this Cristina chick is, Amy's getting my vote.


In the pic's brie put up the 2nd pic looks like amy lee. Are they like cousins or something?

edit//---

Ok. I googed this Cristina chick, and I found this one picture.



I swear to God she looks like Gwen Stefani just with black hair.

[Paradox of Life]

CRISTINA SCABBIA.

People, if you're too lazy to effing google it, don't vote. -____-

I agree, Amy Lee's voice is better than Cristina's, but I like Lacuna Coil a lot more. And Cristina's way hotter.

[inthemudhole]

PEOPLE, I posted pictures of BOTH Cristina Scabbia AND Amy Lee.
Embrace the third post!

Anyway, no... I don't believe they're related.

[*Kathleen*]

Haha. Poor Brie. *Hug* Hmm...it's getting close...blah. I thought for sure I was going to beat Brandon at this.

[JlIaTMK]

OH HELL NO

TOPIC CLOSED.


----

If only I could still do that. =P

Anyways, um... ... you're supposed to uh.... consult meeee before you make this topic?? Duh.

Anyways, Cristina is totally [I'm going to slut myself on Sesame Street].
I still like her though.

Amy gets my vote. I've loved her for the longest time and she's always real. No slutty action paction here and there.

You're boyfriend is a wonderful chooser, you're not. =O

Anddddd, you still have to show me a pictorial of him?

[biglamchops]

Cristina Scabbia is better looking...

[JlIaTMK]

Where's thee makeup? =O

[5ayuri]

I didn't knwo who Cristina Scabbia was. But based on looks she is better looking that Amy lee.

[*Kathleen*]

Oh, come on, Jordan - Amy Lee looks ten times worse without makeup.

[FailedSense]

I voted for Amy Lee because I saw a picture of her somewhere holding a crow, which was just uber hot. ^.^

I like 'em both, though.

[*Weird addiction*]

hmm...this christina lady is definately hotter...wow, like WOW!

[hiromi]

Amy lee looks better, but I think Cristina Scabbia sings better (though both sound way similar)

[yummy_delight]

Christina is hot... but I LOVE AMY LEE!!!!

Amy is beautiful without trying. Christina looks more than a bit whore-ish.

<3333 Amy.

[nyctophiliac]

eww all the Amy Lee fans, I spit on you. Cristina Scabbia is much prettier & has a better voice "hands down".

[Xx majuni xX]

cristina scabbia is definately sexy...i'd totally go for her [if i were a guy].
amy lee's cute...i'd still go for her though...
talent wise, amy lee has an awesome voice.
but i like cristina's music better...[lacuna coil > evanescence]

[starlette]

[Horror],Jul 3 2005, 11:10 PM]Amy Lee
Crz I dunno who Cristina Scabbia is
N I am 2 lazy 2 google it

me too. besides, I love amy lee. Shes a really cool person. And her voice is incredible.

edit//I googled her..she just looks like a wannabe amy lee to me.

[[Mediocre]Artist]

I respect Lacuna Coil; they had the band with the cool chick first. But I just adore Amy. I just wanna pat her head, pinch her cheeks, and steal her clothes.

[inthemudhole]

How can Cristina be a wannabe-Amy if she's been in the industry longer? Seriously, now. Lacuna Coil = from Italy, so we hadn't heard of them until Comalies came out, really, but people assume she 'stole' Amy's style and all of that, but Cristina and Lacuna Coil have been around longer than Amy and Evanescence.

[Paradox of Life]

How can Cristina be a wannabe-Amy if she's been in the industry longer? Seriously, now. Lacuna Coil = from Italy, so we haven't heard of them until Comalies came out, really, but people assume she 'stole' Amy's style and all of that, but Cristina and Lacuna Coil have been around longer than Amy and Evanescence.

Ahaha. Lacuna Coil pwns Evanesence, bitches. Christina's way hotter. Aight, I'll shut up now.

[antix10_kos]

I voted for Cristina but the choices SUCK.

I really vote for Angela Gossow:





In this pic, she shares the spotlight with Cristina....and she owns the pic.

[*Weird addiction*]

^no offense but eww

[antix10_kos]

^no offense but eww

none taken. I just think that Angela is more talented...and she's probably a cooler person than the other two.

[*Kathleen*]

Hmm...I like Arch Enemy too, but Evanescence and Lacuna Coil are compared more often than with Angela. I mean, Arch Enemy is a whole other genre. Even still, I think Cristina's prettier.

[gOODpIRATE]

amy lee. i haven't heard the other chick sing before. oh, and there is another chick out there that sounds like amy lee...i forget what band it is, they aren't that well know yet. when i remember, i post or somthing.

[JlIaTMK]

How can Cristina be a wannabe-Amy if she's been in the industry longer? Seriously, now. Lacuna Coil = from Italy, so we hadn't heard of them until Comalies came out, really, but people assume she 'stole' Amy's style and all of that, but Cristina and Lacuna Coil have been around longer than Amy and Evanescence.

Hm, actually, we haven't heard much of Evanescence til Fallen came out. They had plenty of EP's before that. I wouldn't count on them being in the industry longer. :nods: Briz needs to look up both of their historias before speaking about it. =P

[[Scr3amin][Horro...]

I voted Amy Lee
But after Brie posted the pictures Cristina Scabbia is very pretty too.
In the goth kind of way.
They are both pretty really
Damn Brie your right the first pic of Cristina Scabbia is hawt

[me1issaaaa]

Despite the fact that Amy's gotten more publicity in the media and all, I adore her. I've been a huge Evanescence fan for well over three or four years. Sorry, Kathleen m'dear, but Amy gets my vote.

[inthemudhole]

I looked everything up on both ends. =|

Evanescence history.
Lacuna Coil history.

[TwistMe]

Looks wise I think they're equally matched.

Talent wise (note I'm doing this on voice and not their bands) I'd say Amy Lee was better vocally. This is just me though.

So, I voted for Amy Lee. It has nothing to do with the fact that Amy Lee (Evanescence) had more publicity or they were signed to a bigger label.

[xaznxehgix]

is this based on looks?

[Fallen Fairy]

Amy Lee!
I like her better!

fallen fairy

[inthemudhole]

is this based on looks?

^ Yes... the question above the choices is "Who's hotter?"

[ryfitaDF]

maaaan. you crackas need to look this stuff up. lacuna coil is more talented than evanescense. christina is far prettier. and lacuna coil came first. plus they're better.

[ryfitaDF]

maaaan. you crackas need to look this stuff up. lacuna coil is more talented than evanescense. christina is far prettier. and lacuna coil came first. plus they're better.

[JlIaTMK]

I looked everything up on both ends. =|

Evanescence history.
Lacuna Coil history.

M'dear, Wikipeedeea has nothing. It's just a summary. They have had few before Origin. =P

[inthemudhole]

I know... it said that they had EPs before Origin on the site.

[JlIaTMK]

I know... it said that they had EPs before Origin on the site.

Yep yepppppppppppppppppppppppppppp

Brie, I n33z t0 get da Santey Claus smiley.

[sadolakced acid]

I respect Lacuna Coil; they had the band with the cool chick first.  But I just adore Amy.  I just wanna pat her head, pinch her cheeks, and steal her clothes. 

i want to steal her clothes too, but probably for a different reason.

amy lee. amy lee's like... dignified goth. cristina scabbia is like... slutty goth.

[JlIaTMK]

i want to steal her clothes too, but probably for a different reason. 

amy lee.  amy lee's like... dignified goth.  cristina scabbia is like... slutty goth.

MY GOD. Thank you Justin. I was trying to get that out this whole time but couldn't find a simple way to say it.

[inthemudhole]

Yep yepppppppppppppppppppppppppppp

Brie, I n33z t0 get da Santey Claus smiley.

There you go, buddy.

I don't think Cristina's slutty. Sure, the first picture I posted was a bit revealing, but that doesn't necessarily mean she's slutty.

[*stephinika*]

i don't know cristina that well but yeah she looks a bit better, but i still love amy lee and i love her voice so much.

[nyctophiliac]

about Cristina: if you got it, flaunt it
about Amy: if you don't, cover it up!

[nyctophiliac]

oops double post

[sadolakced acid]

amy wins.

eh: if they don't work, click these links:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

[JlIaTMK]

^ Damn straight y-0.

[sharerol]

amy wins.

All the links are broken.

[sadolakced acid]

All the links are broken. 

works for me.

my favorites are the first and second, and the 4th.

[Chii]

i choose amy lee...

judging by that picture i saw in this post, it seems as if cristina needed a lot of make up to look pretty and tons make up can make ANYONE beautiful...especially if it's a stuff magazine cover

[3ssx]

amy lee.
i have no clue who cristina is

[*Kathleen*]

IF YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHO CRISTINA IS, THERE'S NO ROOM FOR YOU TO VOTE. Dear Lord, people. Secondly, do you really want me to dig up a picture of Amy Lee without makeup? As if she doesn't have any?

[antix10_kos]

ok, for the sake of this thread, i'll just say that i truthfully vote for Cristina. my earlier post of Angela Gossow still stands, however. She may sing a different genre but she too gets compared to Cristina and Amy in some circles.

Cristina does look kind of slutty but I've always taken it to be more a foreign thing than a personal choice. Americans might think she dresses sluttly, Europeans might think it's hot or at least accpetable.... 'Sides, if you got it, flaunt it, right? Cristina is an attractive woman.

Also, people need to consider that the reason that Amy Lee doesn't flaunt it (as far as I know) is that she is a Christian and the whole band was once a Christian band. They still maintain some ties to the Christian community. Therefore, it would look really bad for Amy Lee to walk around in revealing clothes and still hold true to her faith...and her Christian fans....

Proof:
Article 1
"Bring Me To Life"/ Christian Comparisons

Just google for it, they were once a Christian band,...now, well, who really knows???

[fallen_angel1137]

Amy Lee, all the way.

[ktsou11]

yes, i'm in the "who are they?" category... never heard of them.

[duplicatex0x0x0]

amy lee is the lead singer in Evanescence, Cristina Scabbia is um idk..

[sadolakced acid]

IF YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHO CRISTINA IS, THERE'S NO ROOM FOR YOU TO VOTE. Dear Lord, people. Secondly, do you really want me to dig up a picture of Amy Lee without makeup? As if she doesn't have any?

how about dig up a picture of cristina with clothes on?

evanescence= amy lee ( the hott one)
lacuna coil= cristina scabbia (the slutty one)

for those that don't know.

[sharerol]

how about dig up a picture of cristina with clothes on?

evanescence= amy lee ( the hott one)
lacuna coil= cristina scabbia (the slutty one)

Justin, we already get the point that you favor Amy!!



Wow, that was hard to find!

[sadolakced acid]

Justin, we already get the point that you favor Amy!! 



Wow, that was hard to find!   

tug-of-war.

anyways; if you can't be hott without leaving your shirt unbuttoned halfway, then someone else who can be hott without being slutty wins over you.

so...

this:



or this
[attachment=12095:attachment]

[JlIaTMK]

ok, for the sake of this thread, i'll just say that i truthfully vote for Cristina. my earlier post of Angela Gossow still stands, however. She may sing a different genre but she too gets compared to Cristina and Amy in some circles.

Cristina does look kind of slutty but I've always taken it to be more a foreign thing than a personal choice. Americans might think she dresses sluttly, Europeans might think it's hot or at least accpetable.... 'Sides, if you got it, flaunt it, right? Cristina is an attractive woman.

Also, people need to consider that the reason that Amy Lee doesn't flaunt it (as far as I know) is that she is a Christian and the whole band was once a Christian band. They still maintain some ties to the Christian community. Therefore, it would look really bad for Amy Lee to walk around in revealing clothes and still hold true to her faith...and her Christian fans....

Proof:
Article 1
"Bring Me To Life"/ Christian Comparisons

Just google for it, they were once a Christian band,...now, well, who really knows???

Evanescence was never a Christian Band. The media that they recieved pushed their coverage into that direction. As a matter of fact, once they claimed that they wanted to break away from the whole "Christian vibe", all of the Christian music stores rid of their EP's and etc.

Oh, and this....



and this



Sorry, but beauty doesn't always have to come with less weight and boob showage.

[sadolakced acid]

also, bring me to life and going under had some pretty body-hugging clothes...

mmm.

i still like this picture the most

[attachment=12095:attachment]

yummy.

cristina just wears less clothes.

[WhiteLotus*]

^^ I have that poster of her.

Amy gets my vote. I've loved her for the longest time and she's always real. No slutty action paction here and there.

Yes, and that's why she's my role model as well. I have to choose Amy for both on this one.

[mocassinsx29]

I can't really pick, they're both pretty in their own ways THOUGH, if I had to choose who I'd rather look like, Amy Lee gets my vote.

[inthemudhole]

I don't get why you people are trying to change everyone's minds about which person they've chosen.

So you like Amy better.... that is great. Really, it is, but do you have to go around and try and change the minds of the people that chose Cristina as the hotter one?

I don't see many other polls turning out like this one. Everyone just votes and goes, but now some people are trying to force their opinions onto others.

Just vote and go. It's not like this is a debate... it's just a question. There is no need to force your opinion onto someone else.

[sadolakced acid]

i just want to get an excuse to post pictures of amy lee.



god i wish there was a girl in my school that dressed like that and look like that. well, that hot, at least.

[The-Mach-Hare]

ah, what the hey. ill say its a tie and evenly matched.

[sadolakced acid]

the fact that you put amy lee's name first in the title means she's better.

[JlIaTMK]

i just want to get an excuse to post pictures of amy lee.

god i wish there was a girl in my school that dressed like that and look like that.  well, that hot, at least.

But there is me, Justin.

Anyways, I've talked to her and her pleasantness before. Interesting, at the very least, must say.

[sadolakced acid]

But there is me, Justin.

Anyways, I've talked to her and her pleasantness before. Interesting, at the very least, must say.

do you go to my school?

you've met her? you've met amy lee? oh that's sooo unfair. ok, maybe it's fair, but who cares. i want to meet her.

[JlIaTMK]

do you go to my school?

you've met her?  you've met amy lee?  oh that's sooo unfair.  ok, maybe it's fair, but who cares.  i want to meet her.
http://www.createblog.com/forums/uploads/p...-1120888997.jpg

Hrm de dermish. I have her photobucket as well.... =x.

[sadolakced acid]

Hrm de dermish. I have her photobucket as well.... =x.

ehh. stop taunting me.

[aznxdreamer]

amy lee cant sing that well live. but i dno who cristina scabbia is so..amy i guess.

[*danielle_x3*]

Amy Lee.
She keeps it real.

[rx_azngirl]

amy lee. i don't know ho cristina scabbia is.

[sadolakced acid]

amy lee cant sing that well live. but i dno who cristina scabbia is so..amy i guess.

at least she sings live.

[heyyfrankie]

i just saw cristina & she is very hott. maybe just a little bit more than amy lee.

[sadolakced acid]

The error returned was:

Flood control is enabled on this board, please wait 30 seconds before replying or posting a new topic

i just saw cristina & she is very hott. maybe just a little bit more than amy lee.

no, frankie... she's slutty hot... not real hot...

[heyyfrankie]

^ oh, okay. i see, i see.

[j-kwon]

I voted for Amy Lee because I don't know who the hell Cristina Scabbia is.

LMAO YEA ME TOO

[savior]

Cristina Scabbia is by far. Better looking and better voice. Lacuna Coil better music than Evanescense period.
But Sharon den Adel of Within Temptation bypasses both of them in looks and vocals.

Attached File(s)

 withintemp.jpg ( 41.42K ) Number of downloads: 0

 

[sadolakced acid]

hmmm.

sharon doesn't look bad...

but amy does beat cristina.

and cristina's vocals seem more... as accompiament to the male vocals than the main vocals.

oh man i just listened to within temptation.

the band rocks. i love the guitars, the bass, the drums, the piano, yes. i love the riffs, the songs, the melodies.

i hate her voice.

if only she didnt' sing. then it'd be perfect.

[XSuicideflirtX]

this shouldn't even be a discusson Cristina Scabbia and Lacuna Coil far surpass Amy Lee and Evanescense. Scabbia is by far more creative with her vocals and her onstage dress. Scabbia and Coil rule!

[sadolakced acid]

^ christina is just a figurehead. she doesn't even sing the majority of the vocals.

[d0t0rg]

Both over-rated. Fake ass goths.

[kill.t3h.r0cK]

Cristina Scabbia is very sexy, she's my type of girl. =] But, I'm an Amy Lee fan...I voted for Cristina because she is sexier.

[rayburn1301]

*sigh* I am soo tired of the LC and Ev and Amy & Cristina comparisons. They're both great vocalists in great bands. I voted for Amy because she's my number one, but Cristina is amazing too.

[QT_Pnaii_Angel]

AMY LEE!

i am so freakin adikted to evanescence

lol

[XtasyHigh]

Amy Lee
Crz I dunno who Cristina Scabbia is
N I am 2 lazy 2 google it 

ditto.

[SomethingPointy]

WHAT ARE YOU GUYS TALKING ABOUT!?



You're telling me that's ugly?



It's a little big, but you guys had all the shittiest pics of her. In blue? Can you really see what someone looks like when there's some kind of blue light? Amy and Ben started this band when they were 15. 1996. I don't know how long this coil stuff has been around.