A question for those who are intelligent, You views are needed Options

[Hell-Rell]

Okay I got this essay to write by May and the question is "Are the freedoms named in the First Amendment fundamental and if so why?" I need other people views because I don't think mine is right..But what do you guys think?

[*mona lisa*]

Moved to School

[innovation]

Tell me what this is for first. Then, I'll answer. This sounds like the Idea of America Essay Contest. I quote, from the official scholarship website:

Write an essay that examines the historical debate over the benefits and disadvantages of adopting the First Amendment. Are the freedoms named in the First Amendment fundamental and if so why?

I certainly hope you're not ripping off ideas from other people so that you can win $5000.

[silver-rain]

Well, if it is for a scholarship, it should be based on your views, regardless of whether they are right or not, because that's the point: to write an essay arguing your side and views.
And besides, this sounds like an open ended question that asks for your opinion. You should write on what you think, it doesn't matter if your view is right or wrong because there is no right answer.

[*mipadi*]

As others have noted, the point is probably to explore your own thoughts and ideas. Your view is probably not wrong, as long as you can justify your thinking. What are your thoughts on the subject, and how did you arrive at them? Maybe if you discuss your views, others can challenge your ideas, and thus help strengthen your argument.

[illumineering]

Like the others said, post your intial thoughts and rationale. I'd be happy to help in any way once you establish the fact you've taken the time to formulate an initial opinion w/ some justification.

The wiretapping issue involving the circumvention of warrants is an evolving investigation that has a lot of substance that you may use to build a solid rationale for your position.

[Hell-Rell]

Tell me what this is for first. Then, I'll answer. This sounds like the Idea of America Essay Contest. I quote, from the official scholarship website:
I certainly hope you're not ripping off ideas from other people so that you can win $5000.

I know it's a scholarship but my teacher gave it for an assignment ( whats wrong with getting ideas anyways?)

Like the others said, post your intial thoughts and rationale. I'd be happy to help in any way once you establish the fact you've taken the time to formulate an initial opinion w/ some justification.

The wiretapping issue involving the circumvention of warrants is an evolving investigation that has a lot of substance that you may use to build a solid rationale for your position.

Thank you

[innovation]

Evaluation Criteria

NEH will evaluate the essays using the following criteria:

- The essay demonstrates a strong understanding of American history.
- The essay reflects familiarity with primary sources related to the subject.
- The essay demonstrates the student's own serious reflection on the question.
- The essay is focused and well-reasoned.
- The essay is written clearly, with correct spelling and grammar.

^ That means your reasoning, your understanding, and your reflection. Why would they offer $5000 for someone else's ideas?

I'm entering the essay contest, too, and since we have two months to write it, I would recommend skimming through some books for inspiration, if you're really stuck. Books give you examples and ideas, but they're left for you to interpret.