yeah, jacob is nowhere NEAR edward !

I thought the whole point of having a Jacob thread was for Jacob fans, and I really like Jacob : ).

Haha, I agree. Stop saying Edward > Jacob in this thread; you can do that in the Edward thread! :P

Soo...I should really finish rereading Eclipse since I started that over Christmas break. >>;

While my heart is eternally with Edward, I adore Jacob as well. It's hard not to like Jacob. He's the best friend anyone in their right mind would want.

i [heart] BOTH Edward and Jacob! how could you not??? Bella is the one who needs to have a good amount of hate mail ! She ruined BOTH their lives... well not ruined, but made it hard for them! they're both perfect!

I wholeheartedly agree. Bella would be hard-pressed to find anyone else as loyal as Jake is.

^Well, unless Jacob imprints on some unsuspecting chick.
Which I hope never happens...I also hope she can't go trhough with being a vampire and she runs off to live with Jacob forever.

Edward is amazing, but Jacob is that plus more.

I still think that regardless, Bella and Jake will always be the best of friends, even if from a distance. The thing is, Jake is just as risky, if not riskier for Bella than Edward is because he can imprint. Remember Sam and Emily? How much of a heart breaker would it be for Bella to be the "Leah"?

But Sam and Emily... that's true love, right there. And they know it. Anyone would be jealous, regardless of whether they got imprint-left for.

Spoiler:
How crazy is it that Leah can change now and everyone can know her thoughts? That must be awkward.

Leah (thinking): Stupid bastard.
Sam (thinking): I can hear you.
Leah (thinking): I know.

Who is this dude?

... If you read the series, you would definitely know.

If you didn't, then it doesn't really matter.

I still haven't finished Eclipse.

edit:

Does anybody want to contribute icons/siggies/etc for Jacob? Both Taylor Lautner and Steve Strait don't have an abundance of photos to work with. I would like more Jacob love around this forum.

Removed.

i almost wanted to skip over the professing of love parts in eclipse. it was excruciating to read it!
but i can definitely sympthasize with the two of them. i kinda have that dilemma right now with my bf and my best guy friend. i love my boyfriend but my best guy friend just confessed his love for me. unlike bella, i had feelings for my guy friend before i met my boyfriend. CRAZY.
i still don't know which one is my edward though... but i know one or the other will be hurt.

^That sucks.

Who else thinks it would be awesome if Jacob murders Edward at the wedding?
Also, how heartbreaking for Jacob to know that she checks up on him but also know she's still getting married. Maybe Seth should try to repress his thoughts, or not phase. Poor Jacob being stuck in "I love you, just not enough" hell.
I'm glad the first chapter of breaking dawn talks about him, though.
I was afraid Stephenie Meyer might ditch his character because of the whole last line of Eclipse.

Haha, I wouldn't want that. I like both guys, I just favor Jake a bit more.

That would never happen. Breaking Dawn/the rest of the series would be so incomplete if Meyer stopped talking about Jake.

Do you guys think he'll imprint in BD? I really want him to, but I don't think he will. I get the feeling Jake will get the short end of the stick no matter what, unless Meyer can come up with a happy ending for him without sounding cheesy.

I'm gonna start with, I love both Jake and Edward. I'm all for the very tall, warm, tan guy with the sunny disposition though.
People here are hating on him saying that he's selfish to do what he does in Eclipse, but I think that if you were 16 or 17 (however old he is in the book at that point) you probably would react the same to keep the person that you'd attached yourself to so deeply. I would have said to hell with Edward...I love this person and I want them.

Although...you're right about him imprinting on someone else and leaving Bella out in the cold. That would suck a lot. I think he was lying about imprinting on her though. She seems just as attached to Jacob as he is to her, but she's like crazy in love with Edward so in the end...or what has been the end so far, Edward seems to have won.

The Edward/Jacob fight has been going on in my apartment since I forced my roommate to sit down and read the books, which she did in two days. Of course when she decided that she didn't like Jacob she skimmed over most of New Moon and parts of Eclipse...which pissed me off, but that's nothing new. She always calls me the Dog-Lover and is so damn mean about it, but I point back at her and call her the Undead-Lover...and she rolls her eyes. Its a battle, I tell you. I'm for Edward with Bella though...I'll gladly take Jacob if she doesn't want him.

:oD

HAHAHAHAH.. ... NUB..

It's like an argument at my house, too.... Most of my friends (except for one who LOVES Jacob) all LOVE Edward. So, I used to be a: "Go Edward! All the way!" fan but now I'm like: "I don't know... do I like Edward more? Or do I like Jake more?" I started changing sides during Eclipse when Jake started telling Bella that he loved her OVER AND OVER again... So... I'm confused ! I want Bella to end up with Edward though... MY happy story for Breaking Dawn is if:
1)Edward and Bella get married
2)Edward tries to "do" Bella (lol!)
3)Edward changes Bella
4)Jacob imprints on someone besides Bella
and
4)They all live happily ever after
THE END!
But I know that probably won't happen

Like I said, I want Bella with Edward. No doubt. And I have nothing against Edward at all....


...I just love this waaaay more.




Yes, I made this and yes, if you want the wallpaper size version just let me know.
Steven Strait as Jacob all the way...oh yeah.

Blah, I feel like I'm in bellas situation, I'm completely in LOVE with edward, but then theres a spot for jacob also.

Ahaha, other way around for me :)
I just love Jacob.

My best friend saw Taylor Lautner in a tournament
*.* I. Love. Him.



I disagree. I have nothing against Jake and Bella, I just don't think she deserves him after everything that she's done.

O_O Lucky girl! Did she get to talk to him or anything? What was the tourney for?

I totally agree with that.
Everything that she's made Jake go through
made me hate her soooo much.
Like, how she'd use him and urgh!
It just really made me mad.

And what was with all the Jake haters?
I can't see why people would do that.
Stupid. XD

Even though she did all that, I still think Jake would be happiest with her by his side.

This love triangle stuff is always a very good story, but by the end I end up hating one guy or the other.
Every time I re-read New Moon I hate Edward more and more and like Jacob more and more.
They're soulmates damnit!
&Edward is totally gay if he didn't want to do her. I'm spreading that propaganda everywhere. EDWARD IS GAY. Why has he never liked anyone else before? GAY. He got hit on by Tanya and Rosalie and turned them down. GAY. And I repeat again, Bella threw herself at him and he stopped her. GAY. It's like that Katy Perry song: He's so gay and he doesn't even like boys.
Screw Edward and all his gayness. Jacob is a man among men.
Jacob>Edward, The End.

That is contradictory.