is it

shouldnt this go in debate

yes, you will die in fire and go to hell. god hates you.









actually, i don't know.

When we talk about sin we talk about the sins of religion.

Sex before marriage is a sin.
Underage marriage is illegal.
So if you had underage sex, it's a sin.

if youre religious...yes its a sin. you should know that? its in the ten commandments

Premarital sex is a sin.....

It is not in the ten commandments.....but the ten commandments isn't the only thing that determine what is or isn't a sin.

It is also illegal

....it's illegal? really?

Doth is in thine deca Commandments! Under laws 9 and 10! Thou shalt not covet!! which kinda stems down to a bajillion minute infractions and laws. One including no lust for someone unless married.

But isn't in some cultures, you're kind of like married already even before you're born?

yeah it's a sin

haha you people and your sins

If you havnt noticed im not religious

In some cultures you are arranged to be married by your parents with someone else. But not until you're old enough to have children.


[edit] AND support the children.

underage sex = premarital sex = sin.

yes.

It depends on your religion and beliefs.

it's not illegal in california... anywho.... sin or not... i really don't care =\

sin? under christianity, any sex before marriage is a sin.

Yep it's a sin. No doubt. Check your Bible.

lol debate forum...
well, underage sex i consider a sin, but i guess sex before marriage is a sin. but...lol, if you wanna get to the bottom of it, it's illegal...lol so go figure

it was the last time i heard...but that was a few years back...

lust is completely different from premarital sex.....

i know that if you lust...you have already commited adultery...but she asked about underage sex......

to tell you the truth, any sex before marriage is a sin...meh, that's what the people who are religious would tell you...but to tell you the truth..everyone sins...so err..don't wry about it so much?

commandents 9 and 10 are VERY broad, and I do believe they were made broad to cover all the rules in the bible that the other 8 commandments didn't cover. And to an extent, 9 and 10 do branch and stem out to other small specific rules. Premarital sex being one of them.

isn't it.. if you get caught?

firstly, why is this in the lounge? secondly yeah there's a difference between illegal and sin. sin? depends on the religion i suppose. illegal? again depends where.

i'm not religious... so i guess its not a sin for me

Why do you keep saying # 9? What the hell does "false testimony" have to do with underage sex? Ur confused.....and u speek of the "10 commandments" like they are the only laws givin from God. The whole of exodus it self has dozens of more laws given from good....he gets more spicific...some things are "broad" to be left to interpretation....but the 10th commandment isn't one of them.

wow....this is my opinion- underage sex is a sin only if you arent married. If you're married then is ok

its illegal in georgia if youre under 16...other states limit 18 though


but if youre married, then youre probably not under age. states wont allow you to marry before you can legally have sex

its only illegal to til it rape, or thats whati think.

and any sex is a sin unless there's a full motive for it and its for you wanting to get a kid. or i read something like that on a book...

im an atheist, so i wouldnt consider it a SIN.

but i am totally against people that have sex underage. its sick, and most of the time its just to prove something...so watever.

defintly not

state laws and all that, wrong, when you find love then its ok at whatever age, whenever you feel most comfortable doing it.. you don't want to let your chance slide because of misinterpreted laws

rawr O.o

Sex is a sin if your not married. Thats all there it is to it. Even if its because you want a baby for whatever reason, you still need to be married in order for it not to be a sin.

Christians believe that God loves everyone even if they aren't Christian. So even if your not Christian, you still sin. If your not religous, or if you don't belive in God or whatever, Christians and God would still concider it a sin. So just because your not religous, doesn't mean sex berfore marraige isn't a sin for you, it is. Thats what Christians believe.

And yeah, I'm still wondering why this is in lounge....

[shrugs]
I don't know if it IS a sin, but I personally think it should be.

You can have children when you're 12.. what exactly is the "official" age of marriage?

and support the children that you bear. only logical, unless the grandparents decide to take care of them. O.o

no idea the legal age. not gonna try, lest i be flamed.

I'm not sure. The youngest I've herd of was 17 years old. But I'm not sure if thats the minum age or if theres an age younger. (Maybe even older) But it also might depend on where you live.

Uh Oh .....

-Phil-

i think this should be in the debate forum lol??


but anyways... i dont think so.... i mean in biblical times, 13 year old had to sex with a 40 year old man...and they're marriage ages start at 12 to 14 years old.

its a sin but it depends on your culture. in some cultures its probably exceptable, but if you are christian like me, then yes tis a sin. mmmmmmmmmk buh byeeee <3krissy

strange why it would b in the debate fourm.
well yes, in my opinion (im christian), but it depends on the country/state you're living in or whether or not you're religious.

In order to be considered a sin, it would have to be underage as considered by the Bible and God. Of course, when the Bible was written, it was perfectly normal for women (girls?) to get married (and consumate the marriage) at around 10-12 years old. So I don't think underage sex (as we would consider it) is a "sin."

Of course, the whole idea of what is and isn't a sin is so subjective that it's really hard to say for sure.

How "underage" is underage?

As in how old are we considering "underage" here? 17 or younger ?

well premarital sex is a sin
and underaged people are usually not married.

i'm gunna have to go with yes.

what the heck is an underate sex? is there such thing?

...what?

I second that.

premartial sex is illegal?

i dont agree. cali would consider it illegial. i read it's illegial in cali.