saw this article on mtv

read it here:

http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1495008/1...?headlines=true

but if youre too lazy i'll summarize

at the Z100 Jingle Ball where a lot of celebrities were there. lindsay's little 8 year old brother asked joel from good charlotte for an autograph but joel refused since hes romantically linked to hilary. joel went to lindsay's mom and made her have lindsay apologize then he'll give an autograph. but it ended up joel not giving an autograph.

my opinion:
sweet: joel was sticking up for hilary
sad: for lindsay's little brother. i mean hes just a little kid..

wats yur opinion on this

i thought joel and hilary werent true?

but if it was. it's PEDAPHILE! lol (spelling?)

they're like 9 years apart

but i still love both nevertheless

interesting! but it was all "told" by a witness


:edit:// crap i forgot that i just posted, sorry for double posting!!!!

Are you kidding? Joel should be massacred by all his fans (if there are any left?) for this. Refusing to sign for an 8 year old kid because of what his sister did is outrageous. If you're going to stick up for someone you can do it the person not to the innocent little brother who probably had nothing to do with the "feud" as pop culture puts it.



I see the mainstream bands in this country still believe the world revolves around their crappy music.

I'm a wee bit confused. What did Joel want Lindsay to publicly apologize for?

i read the whole article cause i didnt get what you meant, jenny...lol.. and it's so weird...why did lindsay's brother, cody have to make her sister say sorry to hilary duff?!?! i mean there might be faults on hilary duff too.. i bet she didnt say sorry to lindsay lohan, so why does lindsay lohan have to say sorry to hilary duff. o dear what's gotten into hilary duff tsk tsk.

That's messed up! I think Joel should've given him an autograph!

God, that is so screwed up. Lindsay's brother had nothing to do with the feud between her and Hilary. It's so immature of Joel to refuse to give an autograph to him because of his sister.

awwww he shoulda just gave lindseys brother the autograph
her brother had notin do w/ the whole lindsey hillary thing

I know..it's sad

Wow

thats mean, he should've just gave lindsay's brother the autograph, i mean its just a signature -.-

what a @$$hole! poor kid...

Let's set Zakk Wylde on Joel.


Best. Time. Ever.

Agreed.
He just should have.. they could lose fans for that, yah know.

joel's dumb...not like lindsay was the one to ask him for the autograph...poor kid...I'LL SIGN AN AUTOGRAPH FOR YOU!!!!

Lohan is such a female dog.

i love hilary

that's really stupid and childish

i think that they are stupid. your are not going to give a fan an autograph because you are linked to the fan's sister's enemy? and i heard that they didn't hate each other. i just don't know what to think now.

UGH SAME HERE! lol

OMG that's infuriating. joel is an ass. he's acting like an immature middle school doosh. the kid is not even involved in the whole hilary/lindsay thing, and he just refuses to sign a damn piece of paper?

bitch.

Haha I love Joel. I don't like Lindsay Lohan. I like Hilary Duff a lot better. Just 'cause she doesn't act like a total slu+ in her videos.

i like joel, i just wish he wasn't with someone like hilary duff who has no talent whatsoever. i mean, i don't like lindsay lohan either, but come on, he's just a little kid. make him happy and what is joel sticking up for hilary for? he shouldn't not give him an autograph for such a stupid reason. man, celebrities are so selfish and ignorant these days.

Totally agree. Geez, that's immature of Joel to refuse to give the little kid a signature just because he's related to Lindsay Besides, it's not like the little kid had anythig to do with the feud.

Good Charlotte's Joel Madden has allegedly gotten into the middle of the beef between Lindsay Lohan and Hilary Duff.

Backstage at last Friday's Z-100 Jingle Ball radio festival in New York, the pop-punk singer refused to give Lohan's

8-year-old brother an autograph until she publicly apologized to Duff for their ongoing war of words, according to an eyewitness.

Lohan's brother Cody and his friend approached Madden, who had performed that evening with Good Charlotte, and asked for an autograph, the witness said. When Duff, who has been romantically linked to Madden, told him who the kids were, Madden told Cody to get his mother. Madden then allegedly demanded to an outraged Dina Lohan that her daughter apologize for her actions.

This brought Cody to tears, the eyewitness said. But he soon dried his eyes and fired off a jab of his own by asking where the guys from Simple Plan were because, he reportedly said, they were probably nicer. Screams of "Simple Plan! Simple Plan!" then filled the backstage hallways of Madison Square Garden as the boys ran away.

Simple Plan, however, were not on the bill.

Duff performed a short set during the festival, and Lohan was on hand to introduce Destiny's Child.

Lohan's publicist declined to comment on the incident, while a Good Charlotte spokesperson said she was unaware of the incident. Duff's publicist had not returned calls by press time.

The teen pop stars' feud allegedly began when both dated singer Aaron Carter last year.


--- i'm hating joel for this. it's just a signature. it's not like the kid's begging joel to love lindsay. (but i'm not saying i like lindsay) and why is he even sticking up for hilary duff? but i gotta say, "way to go" to cody for getting back at joel. the kid's such a genius!

awww i feel bad for lindsays little brother! he just wanted an autograph! lol, but i guess yay for joel for sayin no to lindsay. lol but i dunno, im not a fan of hilary either, but i feel bad for lindsays bro now

lindsays lil bro had nothin to do with the feud.. joel's such an ass.. i mean its just a signature!!
ps. i hate hilary