Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: I don't understand.
Forums > Resource Center > Webmasters' Corner > Webmasters' Corner Resolved Topics
theerinkal
I submitted a really good layout but It was rejected. The person (I forgot their username lol) said that the image quality was a little low and that the links were not userfriendly.



That is the layout but if you would like to see it live just go to my site. I'm using it on there.

For the image, do I need to host it some place other than photobucket? like Imagshack?

For the links, Does the person mean change the color? or what? I don't understand that part.

I messaged the person asking them those exact two questions.

Thanks for the help in advance! :)

[[erin]]
manny-the-dino
Well judging from the screenshot it is low in quality. But I went into the queue so I could see the live preview &is it low in quality. What did you do to it? Your editing was probably the reason. As far as hosting images, most image hosting sites will compress your images so the only thing you can really do is save as a PNG &/or start off with high quality images. I don't get what they meant when they said the links weren't user-friendly but the navigation is a bit plain & simple. You need to add something that will make your layouts pop. Also the colors you chose don't really match. "/

I just suggest you wait for whoever reviewed your layout to reply back & work from there. thumbsup.gif
theerinkal
QUOTE(manny-the-dino @ Dec 17 2008, 05:04 PM) *
Well judging from the screenshot it is low in quality. But I went into the queue so I could see the live preview &is it low in quality. What did you do to it? Your editing was probably the reason. As far as hosting images, most image hosting sites will compress your images so the only thing you can really do is save as a PNG &/or start off with high quality images.


So your saying that all I can really do is edit the picture differently and the image hosts don't really do anything to the pictures, right?

QUOTE(manny-the-dino @ Dec 17 2008, 05:04 PM) *
I don't get what they meant when they said the links weren't user-friendly but the navigation is a bit plain & simple. You need to add something that will make your layouts pop. Also the colors you chose don't really match. "/

I just suggest you wait for whoever reviewed your layout to reply back & work from there. thumbsup.gif


okay.
Mikeplyts
I'm pretty sure that when whoever told you the links weren't user-friendly, I think they meant it wasn't a real link with the XXXXXX thing at the end.
theerinkal
QUOTE(Mikeplyts @ Dec 17 2008, 09:25 PM) *
I'm pretty sure that when whoever told you the links weren't user-friendly, I think they meant it wasn't a real link with the XXXXXX thing at the end.


what do you mean by the XXXXXXX thing at the end?
manny-the-dino
QUOTE(theerinkal @ Dec 17 2008, 03:48 PM) *
So your saying that all I can really do is edit the picture differently and the image hosts don't really do anything to the pictures, right?

Yes to the editing part & no to the image hosting part. Image hosting sites compress images, meaning your images will loose quality.

QUOTE(theerinkal @ Dec 17 2008, 07:39 PM) *
what do you mean by the XXXXXXX thing at the end?

Lol I think Mike thought this layout was for Myspace. Mike, this layout is for a website.
theerinkal
QUOTE(manny-the-dino @ Dec 17 2008, 09:45 PM) *
Yes to the editing part & no to the image hosting part. Image hosting sites compress images, meaning your images will loose quality.


oh! ok! thanks! I'll wait until the person emails me back.

QUOTE(manny-the-dino @ Dec 17 2008, 09:45 PM) *
Lol I think Mike thought this layout was for Myspace. Mike, this layout is for a website.


Mike....haha! We all have our mistakes.
theerinkal
QUOTE(kring @ Dec 18 2008, 01:43 AM) *
ahmm according to what i have seen in the screen shot, i think you should change the colors..its kind of hurting to the eyes..please don't be offended...however i like your lay.out..+


I'm not offended....why would I be offended? hahahaha!

Okay, I'll change the colors.
theerinkal
QUOTE(divergent @ Dec 18 2008, 05:11 PM) *
Your best advice in this situation, as well as future situations, when you recieve something back from a mod, in this case, your layout was rejected by a design staff member, reply back to the PM that you received and ask them to further their explanation of why it was rejected.


i did that and now i'm talking to him. I'm not that stupid, GOSH!

QUOTE(divergent @ Dec 18 2008, 05:11 PM) *
For me, the colors of the layout and the editing done to the image don't compliment each other very well, and it makes the layout look very unappealing.


Ok like i said I'll change them.

QUOTE(divergent @ Dec 18 2008, 05:11 PM) *
As for the links, I don't think they meant to use the word user friendly, as they are easy to use, and not hard to find. But there is hardly any editing done to them, just some html editing.


What else can I do to them?-I'm using HTML and that's all I'll EVER use.-I mean I can change the color (which is what I was planning to do after I got my domain name up) and add a background but why add a backgruond color that will just look weird on this layout.

_______________________________________________________________________

Everyone on the forums needs to take a chill pill and realize that not everyone is as good as a designer as they are. They should compliment the good things in the layouts or graphics instead of dragging the people down with the bad things that they did. Everyone here is just too uptight and is never nice to people like me who may not have as much expeirence in website design or creating any graphic or layout. You guys are so mean sometimes.
Mikeplyts
QUOTE(manny-the-dino @ Dec 17 2008, 10:45 PM) *
Lol I think Mike thought this layout was for Myspace. Mike, this layout is for a website.


laugh.gif Sorry, lol. I'll make sure I don't make that mistake again. laugh.gif
manny-the-dino
QUOTE(theerinkal @ Dec 19 2008, 10:26 AM) *
Everyone on the forums needs to take a chill pill and realize that not everyone is as good as a designer as they are. They should compliment the good things in the layouts or graphics instead of dragging the people down with the bad things that they did. Everyone here is just too uptight and is never nice to people like me who may not have as much expeirence in website design or creating any graphic or layout. You guys are so mean sometimes.

I know that there are some people that aren't as nice as others but that's the price you have to pay when you showcase your work. I'm not sure if you read the Showcase Booth: Guidelines and Rules of Conduct thread, but you should. There are going to be people that like your work & people who won't & they will tell you what they don't like. It's all a part of becoming a better designer. You have to start from somewhere. I can relate to you because I was in your position when I first started to make graphics & stuff. With the criticism from the design staff & members on here, I learned new techniques & made my graphics better. Whenever I review your work, I try to be as nice as possible, along with the other members. So don't see it as someone bashing your work. Instead see it as a second pair of eyes telling you what you could do to improve your designs.

/long ass response that no one will read
venti-anemoi
QUOTE(manny-the-dino @ Dec 20 2008, 10:43 PM) *
I know that there are some people that aren't as nice as others but that's the price you have to pay when you showcase your work. I'm not sure if you read the Showcase Booth: Guidelines and Rules of Conduct thread, but you should. There are going to be people that like your work & people who won't & they will tell you what they don't like. It's all a part of becoming a better designer. You have to start from somewhere. I can relate to you because I was in your position when I first started to make graphics & stuff. With the criticism from the design staff & members on here, I learned new techniques & made my graphics better. Whenever I review your work, I try to be as nice as possible, along with the other members. So don't see it as someone bashing your work. Instead see it as a second pair of eyes telling you what you could do to improve your designs.

/long ass response that no one will read


I read it. biggrin.gif

theerinkal, there is absolutely no point to posting your work if no one tells you what's bad about it and people only talk about the good things. You won't improve at all that way, which is what you and everyone else wants to see. Sure, some people will focus only on the negative, but you should still take their comments into consideration because that's what'll help you see mistakes or areas of improvement in your designs.

On to the actual layout. The website link didn't work for me, so I can't tell if the image quality problems are just because you sized down the screenshot or if the layout's image itself is bad quality; it seems like a bit of both. Are you using Photoshop? If so, are you saving for web? Try saving it as a .png or .jpeg with maximum quality; it might be compressed too much.

I like the concept of it, but I think you could have chosen better colors for the background and the border around the main content and menu. I also think the layout would look better centered, because the border goes all the way around the image. A repeating background would also make it more interesting, as long as it fits with the layout. I can't comment on the links because I can't see the site, but I think the mod might have meant that it's hard to tell your links from regular text (I'm looking at "topsite, myspace, forums," etc). I'm probably wrong, though.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.