i thought feedback topics were to remain opened until it was mutually agreed upon by both parties that it can be closed.
THOMAS!
Full Version: feedback on feedback
They can be closed when it has been solved. Your specific argument posted here should be referring to moving topics to resolved feedback, and that is only when the feedback is presented to someone or something.
Think back on the Trish layout scandal.
Think back on the Trish layout scandal.
Actually, Spencer is right. Do not move or close Feedback topics until the original topic starter has had a chance to respond.
lol@ people posting feedback topics at the same time a topic on the same subject is posted backstage
also lol @ my current inability to form a complete sentence
No I'm not drunk.
Also because I'm lazy, here's what I posted backstage:
also lol @ my current inability to form a complete sentence
No I'm not drunk.
Also because I'm lazy, here's what I posted backstage:
QUOTE
Agreed, it's not really our place to say an issue's resolved, and it's not exactly a high priority to keep the feedback forum clean. Give it a couple of days and make sure people have had an opportunity to give their input. If it's one person's problem, wait for them to tell us the issue is resolved.
Well something that was improvised, the closing from the actual rule of moving it to resolved feedback...
However, to be fair, here's my reasoning:
However, to be fair, here's my reasoning:
QUOTE
Feedback was sorta getting crammed up. The tutorial one was closed, rather than moved to resolved feedback. I left the topic letting her know she could PM me if she had any other questions, but something that seemed like a resource to you and others was to me, just a topic stating we had three of the same thing. Natalia posted the reason why she accepted all three of them. I let her know that was okay to do, since they provided different methods. What else is left of the topic? Her "O.K." to have it closed?
The thing with the Member's Photos, since it had been implemented, what else is there to discuss, may I ask? Or just for others to reply, good idea, or to have more confusion from the members asking why it was merged? Sorry, I took the liberty of calling it closed before more mundane posts be added to a topic that no longer needed any "feedback".
The thing with the referrals wasn't closed or deleted, but that should have been posted in the questions for official promoters in the first place, so that's where I moved all of the posts refereeing to that.
The thing with the Member's Photos, since it had been implemented, what else is there to discuss, may I ask? Or just for others to reply, good idea, or to have more confusion from the members asking why it was merged? Sorry, I took the liberty of calling it closed before more mundane posts be added to a topic that no longer needed any "feedback".
The thing with the referrals wasn't closed or deleted, but that should have been posted in the questions for official promoters in the first place, so that's where I moved all of the posts refereeing to that.
why does it matter if a forum is crammed? is that not the point?
What's the point?
LOL Guess I'll follow Thomas' lead.
QUOTE
Crammed up? lol
I understand that clutter looks sort of silly, I totally understand that. However, Feedback isn't ever going to be the most tidy forum here.
It's just not our place to shut down threads that haven't even had a chance to breathe. Even when they have, we need to respect people enough to give them ample time, at a minimum, ample warning that if they don't respond in a given time THEN the thread will be considered resolved.
Again, Feedback is for the community. They basically get to take the wheel in that forum if what they are asking/presenting is something reasonable (not spam feedback, for example).
I understand that clutter looks sort of silly, I totally understand that. However, Feedback isn't ever going to be the most tidy forum here.
It's just not our place to shut down threads that haven't even had a chance to breathe. Even when they have, we need to respect people enough to give them ample time, at a minimum, ample warning that if they don't respond in a given time THEN the thread will be considered resolved.
Again, Feedback is for the community. They basically get to take the wheel in that forum if what they are asking/presenting is something reasonable (not spam feedback, for example).
it was Dani's lead first 
I'm leaking my own Backstage shit.
This shouldn't even be an issue.
QUOTE
I don't think it's a very hard concept, but hows about we wait until the topic maker makes it clear that the issue has been resolved. Then we close the topic, and then later on we move it to resolved. Eh?
This shouldn't even be an issue.
Resolved?
SPENCER!
SPENCER!
no
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.