Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: HP books
Forums > Community Center > Academia > Books
ji_cabinx
Which one of the 5 harry potter books is your favorite?
inlonelinessidie
I feel so bad for saying this but . . . I've never read a Harry Potter book ever. _unsure.gif fallen.gif
tweeak
QUOTE(inlonelinessidie @ Jun 17 2004, 3:29 PM)
I feel so bad for saying this but . . . I've never read a Harry Potter book ever. _unsure.gif fallen.gif

^ *gasp shock* go read them NOW!!!

i think they get progressively better, so the 4th or 5th
refreshe
The fifth (just read it) even though fallen.gif Sirius dies cry.gif
inthemudhole
I'd say.. the 2nd or 4th.
rivendell
Prisoner of Azkaban is my total favorite. Goblet of Fire is a close second. happy.gif
01-supergirl
LOLS, never read a single book. It kinda got confusing for me...
FreeStickers
4th and 5th combined! So...foufth! Harry Potter is suuuuper. biggrin.gif
jaeman
Believe it or not, I have only read the first one. I have never read the second one but the movie makes it more understandable. I know I won't be able to read the third one because there is already a movie out on it. The fourth and fifth ones I will probably never know because without the previous storylines, the fourth and fifth ones will be like some kind of gibberish! huh.gif
ji_cabinx
QUOTE
Believe it or not, I have only read the first one. I have never read the second one but the movie makes it more understandable. I know I won't be able to read the third one because there is already a movie out on it. The fourth and fifth ones I will probably never know because without the previous storylines, the fourth and fifth ones will be like some kind of gibberish! 


u should read the book...then watch the movie...the books are way better than the movies!
silver-rain
everyone should read the books now!
hmm, i liked the 3-5 book, except for the part where sirius dies... cry.gif
JlIaTMK
ive only read the first one and part of the second one sad.gif but im gona read them over the summer
whomps
Uhm.. The fourth one. Yeahhhhhhh.


But they're all good.
Kitsune_black666
I second the vote for the fourth one. In my opinion, her writing gets better and better with every book. I think i heard she was going to go back and re-write them to make the first ones better, actually
Luster Soldier
Definitely the third one. I read it twice! That's like, such an accomplishment for me!
shortie09
the fifth one, where the truth is revealed about harry's parents and his link to neville. poor neville. ermm.gif
phatty
i loved number 3 and 5!
gigglepot
I loved PoA, but the latest one was really good too.
Winter
I've only read the 1st and 5th one... So I have no idea.Lolx..
iheartsimba
4th I think. I only read the 3rd and 4th though =]

i lost my 5th book!
kryogenix
QUOTE(inlonelinessidie @ Jun 17 2004, 3:29 PM)
I feel so bad for saying this but . . . I've never read a Harry Potter book ever. _unsure.gif fallen.gif

Good for you! I wish, but I was subjected to the first 2 books in the series before I came to the conclusion that it's not worth reading even though there was a lot of hype surrounding it.
glit_gal
3rd and fifth books were the best. although it's kinda ironic that those books were when we first meet sirius and when he dies.
meisperson
me ithink forth or maybe fifth but forth shifty.gif not the fifth one becuz sirius died cry.gif cry.gif cry.gif cry.gif cry.gif cry.gif cry.gif cry.gif
distortedMIND
I'd have to say fourth.
dani41790
i like the second. the first is ok, the third is kinda boring, and the fourth n fifth r sad
swe3txprincesz
i luv them all! i read them all atleast three times, malfoy is hot! biggrin.gif
LatinaLady
QUOTE(inlonelinessidie @ Jun 17 2004, 2:29 PM)
I feel so bad for saying this but . . . I've never read a Harry Potter book ever. _unsure.gif fallen.gif

dont feel bad.
i havent read a single one either
xquisite87
I'd say the 3rd book is my favorite. I saw the movie and no offense but the movie kinda made the book look bad. I mean the book was really, really, really good and the movie was just really not as good as i thought it'd be _dry.gif
smileyamers
goblet of fire! thats the 4th right? haha...
i fell asleep during the 1st movie and didn't watch any of them after that. =/ oh well...the books are good tho
ji_cabinx
the books are def. better than the movies, but they aren't bad either!
Flaunted
3rd book.
i just loved the third book
4th is second.
5th is third
1st is fourth and
2nd is last

yea thats how i liked it.
:)
gelionie
the order of my liking of HP books:

HPPoA (3rd) -> HPOoTP (5th) -> HPGoF (4th) -> HPPS (1st) -> HPCoS (2nd
crazeegirl411
THIRD ONE with not hesitation! Even if her writing was not as better, the story overall hits its climax right there. The second is the worst so far, because it was slowly crawling to the climax. The fourth and fifth are okay because it seems like it's droning too much, and reading a person's diary.

Harry Potter may not be as good and deserve the hype and all...but it definitely should be read. I feel sorry for the people who never took the chance/time to read it ermm.gif

By the way, everyone who skipped books 1-3 just because of the movie...I reccomend you to read the books and forget about the movie (even though I think it'll seem weird). The books are definitely better, the movie wastes my time.
BlondE x Babii
tha 4th one is really good it keeps you interested but so is the 5th on... i would say right now its a tie between the 4th and the 5th happy.gif i cant wait to read the 6th one too... does anyone know when its coming out??

* and i agree with crazeegirl411 because the books are wayy better than the movies... the movies leave out alot of the detail that the book had...
mizz_mithy
i luv the third one. the fourth one was good too.
abstracted
Hmm, a lot of people don't like the fifth so much because it's sad, angsty, and Harry sounds like he needs some anger management. But, I like it the best. There's more about the Marauders (in their time! I love them happy.gif ), and the Order, and it's just more realistic (well...as realistic as magical book can get). I really like the fifth, even though ___ died. cry.gif
smrkangl
I really really like GOF.... _smile.gif
ichiban
i think all of them were awesome .. props to rowling _smile.gif
EmeraldKnight
QUOTE
Hmm, a lot of people don't like the fifth so much because it's sad, angsty, and Harry sounds like he needs some anger management. But, I like it the best. There's more about the Marauders (in their time! I love them  ), and the Order, and it's just more realistic (well...as realistic as magical book can get). I really like the fifth, even though ___ died.

Haha yeah, I agree with you. I thought the fifth was Rowling's masterpiece thusfar..
HiddenFaerie
QUOTE(iheartsimba @ Jun 19 2004, 12:01 PM)
i lost my 5th book!

-gasp- I did too! It's an epidemic I tell you. lol, I think I left it someplace at school. Which means it's gone for good! I think I like the fourth book the best. Harry is oh so heroic... biggrin.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.