Well I worked a tad bit harder on this one, and I think its pretty good. What do yall think?

Looks pretty good, it needs a border though.

Not bad, I'd only suggesting aiming for higher quality and making the font readable. Otherwise not bad.

It's rather low quality, and the font is pretty hard to read. Other than that it's okay.

It's nice!
I agree with adding a border, though.
And, I think the font should..pop out more.
I like it, though.

I disagree about the border. I think a border wouldn't look very good with it, just because of the way it was made.
It would be good if the quality and font were better. But it's pretty good.

the font = nasty but other then that it looks good. try to fix that though

i like it...maybe use different font though

There's definitely room for improvement.

Just so you know, it's Elizabeth Swann, not Swan.