Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: moderator for a day
Forums > News and Announcements > Feedback > Feedback Resolved Topics
Pages: 1, 2, 3
AngelicEyz00
eyebrowes.gif
kryogenix
If drafted, I will not run; if nominated, I will not accept; if elected, I will not serve.
The Markster
Seems fun and tempting, but I don't think the mods will like it. happy.gif
AngelicEyz00
Why wouldn't they like it? Unless they're Nazis. Which only the Hitler wannabe is.
The Markster
QUOTE(AngelicEyz00 @ May 22 2007, 09:28 PM) *
Why wouldn't they like it? Unless they're Nazis. Which only the Hitler wannabe is.

Oh wait, you mean someone will be elected to be a moderator for a certain day?
AngelicEyz00
Yessir.

// Well, not really elected, per se. Some sort of a contest where the winners get to be mods for a day... or whatever.
StanleyThePanda
QUOTE(The Markster @ May 23 2007, 12:27 AM) *
Seems fun and tempting, but I don't think the mods will like it. happy.gif

Why do you think that? _smile.gif

Sounds like a very interesting idea, Elba. thumbsup.gif
I like it. teehee.
digitalfragrance
What kind of contest? Because we couldn't just have ANYBODY be a mod for the day... imagine the chaos... *shudder*

I'm for it, as long as the contest winner would be somewhat qualified... as in the contest proves it, or something.

It's late and I'm rambling, so I'm done.
JoanOfArc
Oh man, we would not see the end of that. That sure seems interesting though...hm. We need some guidelines on who can enter though. whistling.gif
The Markster
I'm for it, then, too! Wow, how fun!
[2]Nekked
kinda funny. elba and i were both a part of the original staff. and kryo too.
AngelicEyz00
Aw, you guys are already wanting to limit who gets to be mod sad.gif
gelionie
I would like to see more guidelines set on this thing before I know whether I'm for or against the idea.
digitalfragrance
QUOTE(AngelicEyz00 @ May 23 2007, 12:46 AM) *
Aw, you guys are already wanting to limit who gets to be mod sad.gif


Well, we can't just have anybody... what if someone went through and rejected all of the graphics? Or closed and deleted topics that shouldn't be? I mean, there has to be some sort of common sense in who can and can't be a mod for the day.
AngelicEyz00
QUOTE(digitalfragrance @ May 22 2007, 09:49 PM) *
Well, we can't just have anybody... what if someone went through and rejected all of the graphics? Or closed and deleted topics that shouldn't be? I mean, there has to be some sort of common sense in who can and can't be a mod for the day.

Well if they get power hungry, then the admins can just demote them.
StanleyThePanda
^ thats true.

And if they make a mess, it shouldnt be too hard to clean up.
But maybe some guidelines should be set. I mean... All contests have some sort of guidelines, ya know?
AngelicEyz00
Yes, of course.
gelionie
^ what if there's no admin on at that time?
You can MAKE A HUGE MESS if the limit is one whole day, you know.
AngelicEyz00
As long as they're not allowed to delete anything, I don't think that such a big mess can be made.

How about if you f**k up, you get suspended for 30 days, haha. That should give them a reason not to make a big mess, eh?
gelionie
^ that's a good punishment I think.
The Markster
QUOTE(AngelicEyz00 @ May 22 2007, 10:00 PM) *
As long as they're not allowed to delete anything, I don't think that such a big mess can be made.

How about if you f**k up, you get suspended for 30 days, haha. That should give them a reason not to make a big mess, eh?

Good punishment, but you'll never know. Someone could at least take advantage, spite the 30-day consequence, and just majorly misuse their powers and ban whoever they see.
[2]Nekked
an admin can create a new staff group with very limited access to mod functionality. i.e. no banning/suspending/warning. you should only get to moderate topics (open/close/move) and view backstage crap.
AngelicEyz00
Now that it seems like it's going to be so limited, it doesn't seem that fun anymore.
gelionie
^ but we just have to set up those restrictions in case someone really goes overboard with the mod powers... even it's just a day.
AngelicEyz00
Or we could just trust that they wont. Meh, I dunno.
Rachel
QUOTE(AngelicEyz00 @ May 23 2007, 12:01 AM) *
Or we could just trust that they wont. Meh, I dunno.

That's the issue here. Mods don't trust members, members don't trust mods. Le sigh, I miss the olden days.
clarity
I like this idea.

Maybe they could have functions to all features, but like for the major ones features they'd need to be approved by a real moderator to carry out?
HakunaMatata
QUOTE([2]Nekked @ May 22 2007, 10:56 PM) *
an admin can create a new staff group with very limited access to mod functionality. i.e. no banning/suspending/warning. you should only get to moderate topics (open/close/move) and view backstage crap.
Kaycee's turn to play Nazi, I guess.

I like the limited access to being a new staff-ee, and I'd love people to give people a chance to be a mod - but I am very very wary of letting them view Backstage. And I know, I know, the mods have such trust issues and such and such and that being able to view Backstage is such a big part of being mod, but I just can't see us letting people see Backstage so easily and quickly just like that, even for a day.
Duchess_of_Dork
I think that this merits some thought. After the dust settles from CB4 a bit, perhaps we can look at what some of the options could be, from an access standpoint.

The idea of this is fun, but what would be the criteria (what would the contest consist of)?
kryogenix
QUOTE(HakunaMatata @ May 23 2007, 07:48 AM) *
Kaycee's turn to play Nazi, I guess.

I like the limited access to being a new staff-ee, and I'd love people to give people a chance to be a mod - but I am very very wary of letting them view Backstage. And I know, I know, the mods have such trust issues and such and such and that being able to view Backstage is such a big part of being mod, but I just can't see us letting people see Backstage so easily and quickly just like that, even for a day.


Yeah, if I was a shit talker backstage, I wouldn't want anyone seeing it either.
steve330
Trust gets you no where nowadays. There will always be people that you think you trust but once they get a hold of power they get corrupted and become more and more power hungry. A lot of mods are like that already, and they'll close shit or warn people over insignificant shit or banters that are to be expected.

I used to be in ROTC (rofl I know) and there was a contest and whoever won would be Commanding Officer for the day. The person who ended up winning really didn't do shit and it was more novelty than anything. I think if someone were to win mod for the day they would just kinda go around trying to have a fun time with their new found powers and not really do anything helpful or beneficial and probably only do stuff that detriments the site more than anything else.
relaxdontrelapse
why so wary about us seeing backstage?
!!!!!!&#
I don't mind the idea in theory. I just think o many restrictions would have to be put in place that any real 'reward' or whatever, would be lost.

Out of interest, why do people think that it would be such a great reward in the first place?

QUOTE
That's the issue here. Mods don't trust members, members don't trust mods. Le sigh, I miss the olden days.
With all due respect, love, there were plenty of problems in the 'olden days' as well... People sugaring the past is part of the reason why there i sso much dissent about the new 'regime' or what ever people w2ant to call it.
Duchess_of_Dork
So what would the contest be like? What would the contestants (for lack of a better word) do? Would there be like a campaign or something?
YourSuperior
QUOTE(haveahappyday @ May 23 2007, 11:22 AM) *

I think a fair way to pick someone, is you would have to look at the person, if they are an active member of the forums, not just someone who just signed up and wants to be Moderator for a day. I think that the contest should be limited to people who have no warning level. The person that gets chosen could not be a person who violates member terms often, this person would have to submit a clear description as if they were running for a moderator position, as if moderator positions were open. The person, or people that choose the winner of the contest would have to look at the user submitted description, and have to see if that person would be fit for a moderator position. before given the moderator position for the day, the person would have to agree not to violate the terms which are set up in the contest guidelines, etc..

I'm going to have to agree with everything that he just said. Because you couldn't just have some person just running haywire with the moderating powers.
Jeng
GOOOD IDEA ELBAAA, so smart :D
hehe, uhmm I'm in for this :D
Have some sort of guidelines, the member must follow, liek have requried ppd..etc, and restrictions of course
MyMichelle
I liked this idea until it got too practical.

f**k LIFE.


We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
insurmountable
haha I'm all for it. Sounds like an interesting idea, although I don't know how exactly someone would get to become mod for a day. Perhaps the staff just puts together a list and then changes the person each day or something. -shrug-

Although at some point in time, I think the staff will get some little judgment against it and just drop it and say they can't do it anymore. Or it will get way to biased and others won't get a fair try.
The Markster
I still think it's a fun idea, though it would suck if someone was picked for a day and was totally busy that day .. or if they didn't have anything to mod. Lmao.
MyMichelle
Well... I guess that can be worked out for the winner. They can choose the day?

If the idea goes, that is.
loveylovely
This is a really good idea, kind of like a "let's-pick-a-new-mod-and-let-them-try-before-they-buy" sort of thing. rolleyes.gif
moorepocket
QUOTE(kryogenix @ May 23 2007, 12:26 AM) *
If drafted, I will not run; if nominated, I will not accept; if elected, I will not serve.

no one cares what you do anymore.
AngelicEyz00
laugh.gif damn kryo, you going to take that from moorepocket?
Duchess_of_Dork
QUOTE(MyMichelle @ May 23 2007, 08:32 PM) *
I liked this idea until it got too practical.

f**k LIFE.


We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
We all live in a yellow submarine, yellow submarine, yellow subarmine...
That's one of the first songs I ever remember listening to. XD

How "too practical"? If this were to happen (and I really do think it's a fun idea) what do you think would make it less practical or rigid that would keep it fun? :]
QUOTE(insurmountable @ May 23 2007, 09:50 PM) *
haha I'm all for it. Sounds like an interesting idea, although I don't know how exactly someone would get to become mod for a day. Perhaps the staff just puts together a list and then changes the person each day or something. -shrug-

Although at some point in time, I think the staff will get some little judgment against it and just drop it and say they can't do it anymore. Or it will get way to biased and others won't get a fair try.

Chin up, girl! Don't doom it before it has a chance. ;]
QUOTE(MyMichelle @ May 23 2007, 11:00 PM) *
Well... I guess that can be worked out for the winner. They can choose the day?

If the idea goes, that is.

Absolutely. I think they (the person who wins) should be able to pick they day that they are available.
relaxdontrelapse
QUOTE(relaxdontrelapse @ May 23 2007, 12:38 PM) *
why so wary about us seeing backstage?
MyMichelle
QUOTE(Duchess_of_Dork @ May 24 2007, 06:19 AM) *
That's one of the first songs I ever remember listening to. XD

How "too practical"? If this were to happen (and I really do think it's a fun idea) what do you think would make it less practical or rigid that would keep it fun? :]


I think the mod should be allowed to do almost anything, hahaha. Except completely destroy cB. Of course, the person would be chosen carefully, so they wouldn't be someone who would enjoy in the destruction of cB. But limiting them so they can only rearrange and edit stuff? ._. That would seem kind of lame.
steve330
At first the idea does sound pretty fun and novel. When it all comes down to it you can't really trust a lot of people, and if it's just for one day then they are going to want to get the most out of it, which would mean doing everything they can using every power they could. Someone mentioned it as a trial for new mods, which actually sounds like a good idea, but you would have to get nominated to be an upcoming mod for that to even make sense *Shrug*.
davinci
Sounds like a pretty cool idea. And keeping all moderating abilites sounds fair to me; otherwise, they would be a 'true' moderator. Besides, if they do something bad, they'll be caught. ;)

One problem I can foresee is people sharing their passwords. Meh. Mods will have to trust the mod-for-a-day-mod so it's only fair for them to keep that trust.
StanleyThePanda
^ Definitely agreed.
QUOTE(relaxdontrelapse @ May 23 2007, 01:38 PM) *
why so wary about us seeing backstage?

shrug.gif Whooo knows?
After thinking about it for awhile, I really couldn't think of why it would be a big deal...

But yeah, I'm still up for this.
relaxdontrelapse
QUOTE(StanleyThePanda @ May 24 2007, 11:58 AM) *
^ Definitely agreed.

shrug.gif Whooo knows?
After thinking about it for awhile, I really couldn't think of why it would be a big deal...

But yeah, I'm still up for this.
exactly. everything we say is said in public so why should the staff be allowed to hide what they say. it seems you guys rely on backstage too much to express your opinions on other members rather than using it to keep in contact of new ideas and ways to improve the site. if it's too much of a site for us to see, i think it's being abused.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.