these were the first icons that I used colouring with.. lol first I was like nono they'll hurt my feelings by saying things about my icons, then I was like toughen up you want to get better right? so here they are.. critque away

Actually there ok to me! I like the first one, but I don't know if the stars are in teh background or pasted on because I think theres too many. Maybe loose one in the top let hand corner. The second one is cute, the text is hard to read though so thats the only thing I'd suggest fixing. The quality looks abit low as well but otherwise their not bad.

They are good, you shouldnt be scared of us. I really like the 2nd one, other than the font being hard to read.
I also agree with Toya about the stars and the quality. But with practice, you'll be amazing.

Second one=goooooodd!!!
just fix the font/color

Exactly what I was thinking about the first one!
It's really cute, but maybe loose a star.
The second one is super great. It's so sweet.
Nice job!

thanks...=D yeah i'll work on it a bit more.... dang !!

Awe I love the second one! The colors look so good in it. The first one I don't know what is it, I think it just looks like any ordinary anime icon and it doesn't have any special touches to it that stick out to me.

Adore the second one though

It's Quistis from FFIII .. ( you know the one with rinoa and squall ect..) thanks!