I think your style is pretty unique. It's too bad that other people have that style now, too. Maybe you could try interesting color combinations with the shirts? I'm not really sure, and you didn't say what color your two shirts are. Maybe you could also have an accessory of some sort that's not a hat...like a necklace or something. Something cool and simple.
Totally unrelated, but you live in New York? So do I, I live in Queens.