ehh lindsay all the way..in that movie mean girls she looked hooott!

I would say Lindsay? I'm not sure.

Lindsay fa sho!

Lindsay, cuz i cant stand Hilary!!!!!

Lohan!!! I can not take the site of duff... she is a fake. I think she can not sing and just because she is a actor she also gets a sountrack? I dont htink that is right and linsay is 100% awesome.

moved to entertainment.

Lindsey, Duff is so annoying and can't sing she should've not try to ask for a huge raise and continued Lizzie Mcguire

i like lindsay better! she's WAY better!

lindsay lohan!!!!!! ^_________^"

LINDSAY LOHAN!!!!!!

Cause she's not another britney spears look alike.

totally agree. hillary annoys the hell out of me! haha

lindsey

HAH hilary is cute, but i think lindsay is hot also!

Lindsay, only because the one thing I can't stand about Hilary is her voice.

i think lindsay is both a better actress and singer..however i like hilary as well..just not as much

Definately Lindsay!

Lindsay! Shes hot. Young but hot.

i will jump you if you like hilary duff.

on live television, lindsay lohan said on MTV, "i love you hilary duff". something like that. and i heard she said that because the two had a fight over aaron carter [nick carter`s little brother].

lindsay lohan was DEFINITELY lying. i bet she was like "i LOVE you hilary duff...psh..NOT!"

ahahaha!

Man, I hate Hillary Duff. She just would've stuck to acting-- not singing. Plus she stole Chad. C`mon, Hilary Duff's song, "Let the rain come down and wash your face?" What the--?! Is my face too dirty for you, HILARY!? Do you think your better than ME?! Well, guess what? You're not!

Sorry, got carried away there.

Their both hott.

lindsay all the way!!! i can`t stand hil, i wish i could tho

omg...LOL!!!

ahahahahahha!!!

that`s just hilarious..

it`s her face that`s DIRRTY.

Lindsay
Hillary is too...goody girl
But I hear Lindsay is a real biAtch
Who knows.

i picked lindsay lohan cuz i jus cant stand hillary duff. man i think she cant act, or sing at all. she gives me this nausiating feeling everytime i c her on tv or in a magazine

i think lindsay lohan is better in acting and singing because she's more mature.. hilary's voice is like a little kid and her acting is always that "ugg".. "arggg" type

I totally agree lol. I don't know what Lisay Lohan's personality is but she seems cool =D Plus, erg I can't stand Hilary Duff in her show LIzzie McGuire. Man, her acting ruins the show lol. And the plots in each episode.. it's so darn sterotypical. They show creates this whole feeling that...
1. YOU NEED to be popular for people to like you
2. The ONLY boys that are CUTE are those dumb/confused guys, that everyone should LIKE those type of guys.
3. Even if she does try to deal with real life issues, they are boring and she tries to act all "cute" and hopes that it will be "funny" but it's NOT.
4. Yea okay little brothers can be difficult and stuff, but at least make him funnier. No the kid Lenny that doesn't talk is NOT funny, IMO of course.


Erg I loathe that show so much. I might even try to watch the Lizzie McGuire movie just to see if she still acts so boring in that movie as well. MAYBE. And her singing? Erg eya she just like another Britney wannabe. Except she tries to make it into a rock version.

I don't like how Disney is shoving Hilary Duff down our throats, even though they're doing the same with Lindsay Lohan, but I just like her better. She has the photographic memory, which is a quality Chad Michael Murray possess, so obviously, the winner is Lindsay.

hilary thinks she's all that...i mean, she got to celebrate her b-day in hawaii and got her own soundtrack...that is so bit*hy..so,"GO LOHAN!" she rocked in mean girls!

hilary! i think hilary sings better, but lindsay acts better. and i alway sliek the sweeter one more.

HILARY ALL THE WAY! *Starts singing along to Hilary CD whilst wearing his "I love Hilary Duff" t-shirt*

lindsay..no doubt about that one..

i like Lindsay better. i have a magazine where Lindsay is like i wish our conflicts can end and all and she say I love you Hilary Duff. even if it wasn't true, she was still nice about it. Hilary was like, "everytime i see her she talks bad about me". and Hilary started having fits and crying when Lindsay went to the premiere of Cheaper by the Dozen. pshh..Hilary's such a baby. plus she can't sing or act.

sorry if anyone likes Hilary. i was stating my mind

LINDSAY LOHAN all the way man!!!!!!!!! I can't stand hilary! she can't even sing. And lindsay is a better actress. she was awesome in the movie mean girls

lindsey because in mean girls she was hilaroius and pretty hot ..

i`d prefer none. but if i had to choose, it`d be lindsay. i liked mean qirls

lindsey all the way she is hot. lol. she seems better than hilary.

Lindsay. Unlike Hillary, she can actually act.

hmm.. I picked L.L but I'm unsure.. they both seriously cannot sing. I guess I picked lindsey lohan b/c her movie mean girls seems.. way better than what hillary has. The parent Trap was awesome. lmao.

they say all celebrities are bitches. people are people. we're all bitches at one point or another. hehehehe

i like lohan better.

i think they're both really pretty~

Lindsay definitely.

i personaly like lindsay lohan more.

Linsay lohan cause she is like 40 times hotter than hillary and stuff... yeah...

Lindsay. She's really pretty too. lol

i would say lindsay because i HATE hilary duff....*cough* cant *cough* sing *cough*

Yeah.. I don't know what is it that makes Lindsay seem so cool. A LOT COOLER THAN HILARY. I absolutely loathe her. I'm not afraid to admit that she looks pretty SOMETIMES (like in that one video..) but still. she can't sing, and I think her stupid character in the Lizzie Mcguire show made her image go down the hill. She sucks.


But I guess when I think about it.. It's kinda sad when you've tried your best and everyone still thinks your a fake and hates you.

Oh wait, nvm. Lindsay >>>>> Hilary

Lindsay. she's wayy better. hands down.

i think is lindsay lohan... duh! she's like way better than hilary. hahaha *laugh*

ok i already made a topic bout this before

Lindsay.

Don't ask me why; I'm just going with the flow.


Actually, I'm choosing her over H. Duff because Mean Girls was somewhat amusing.

Definitely Lindsay. She's beautiful and seems more down to earth.