Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Idol: Fantasia or Diana?
Forums > Community Center > Movies & TV
allen
Who do you guys think is going to be the American Idol 04? Personally, it should've LaToya London, cause she just blew me away with every performance. But between Fantasia Barrino and Diana DeGarmo (the final 2), I really don't know. I'd like to think Fantasia, but if you heard Diana's 'Don't Cry Outloud' performance last week, you never know. I can't wait to watch tomorrow! :D
CEP
Diana.
She's so cute! Have you seen her when she laughs?!
~^_^~

- Chinkieeyedpnoi
iambaybala
i want diana to win
Senorita_Babo
they both suck, but if i must choose, fantasia, she's older, wiser and sings better.
angel-roh
sniff does anyone live in seattle, washington that can let me watch american idol at their house cus my channels are broken...sniff i wana see how much american idol is so fun... wat do they do there? jus show their singing career? is that all? and then to see who wins? is that all...hmm... uhh ok
xquizit
I agree... Latoya London should have been American Idol but I guess voters don't know real talent with they hear/see it. _dry.gif But out of the two that's left I'd say Fantasia. She puts so much emotion into her singing and I really love that about her. She has spunk.
WhiteChocolate
I liked both Fantasia and LaToya. I was really dissapointed when LaToya was voted off, and that was definitely a wrong decision. I swear that American Idol is rigged...anyway, I definitely hope that fantasia beats the little bubbly, annoying white girl (Diana) lmao...
onenonly101
Diana deserves to win because she has been great since the first time she appeared on Idol, but she is from Georgia. But i also love Fantasia because she can sing and she has grown throughout the time she has been here, but i don't think america is ready for her
WhiteChocolate
QUOTE(onenonly101 @ May 25 2004, 11:00 AM)
Diana deserves to win because she has been great since the first time she appeared on Idol, but she is from Georgia. But i also love Fantasia because she can sing and she has grown throughout the time she has been here, but i don't think america is ready for her

She has so much personality, though. I think that she's really loveable and entertaining! (I mean fantasia)
sweetlyz
i really have no clue cause i haven`t been following up on the show. i stopped after the first one. hehe, i dunno .. just didn`t wanna watch it so much. once in awhile i`ll flip through the channels and see it on and maybe i`ll watch it for a bit .. but gRrR, Ryan Seacrest bugs me everytime he says "right after this commercial" and crap .. so i usually end up watching something else.
THAT-ONE-GIRL-143
i think diana is going to win..i dont like either of them tho..their voices are too nasaly and they just bug me..
StarryEyedSurprize
im for Diana! shes awesome
pimpin231
QUOTE(iambaybala @ May 24 2004, 11:19 PM)
i want diana to win

fu*ck that NC rep fan all the way boxing.gif
LiNHy POO
i say fantasia... she's much better than diana!
immersion31
i dont really care bout idol since jasemin was voted off
illuminessence
FANTASIA ALL THE WAY BABY! Although, I like Diana too, but what America needs is someone different from all other female singers, and Fantasia is the one. happy.gif
X serenity
la toya should've won. hammer.gif since she was voted off, fantasia should win now, because she's different. she has a different personality, and she's just different. laugh.gif
f00LisH_h3aRt63
im gonna have to say diana....she has a awesome voice. and yea so does fantasia but i dont like her attitude. so count on me voting for diana tonite.

throb.gif jackie
najae
im stuck as to who to vote for; i was rooting for diana, and i thought her performance last week was fantastic, but fantasia did just an awesome job as well! _smile.gif so im just gonna vote for both. whoever wins at this point, i'll be happy biggrin.gif
xislandxstylex
I want Diana to win. Fantasia's good but she reminds me of Macy Gray.
triipinfserious
i think fantasia; shes not as good as a singer as diana, but she can pump up the crowd `nd such
xquizit
I don't know bout ya'll but I love Fantasia's performance for "Summertime". ohmy.gif
illmizzkim
Ooh ! I like Diana way better than Fantasia, but she kinda messed up in one of her songs.. I think Fantasia is going to end up winning though.
illmizzkim
I think Jasmine is way hotter than all of them though!




biggrin.gif
Senorita_Babo
QUOTE(illmizzkim @ May 25 2004, 7:54 PM)
I think Jasmine is way hotter than all of them though!




biggrin.gif

sure, she's prettier, but she can't sing.
compleXperception
i HOPE diana... fantasia sounds like macy gray - turned chipmunk on helium...
orlando_bloom_luva
i watched part of it today..... fantasia wasnt that good... i think fantasia has a good chance of winning but im voting for diana
onenonly101
Fantasia was EXCELLENT last night. Diana was too sacred and she was off-key most of the time. Fanatasia better when. the last two songs she sang were amzing, the idol single was written for her voice
pimpin231
QUOTE(onenonly101 @ May 26 2004, 11:16 AM)
Fantasia was EXCELLENT last night. Diana was too sacred and she was off-key most of the time. Fanatasia better when. the last two songs she sang were amzing, the idol single was written for her voice

yup fan is the best nc rep biggrin.gif
darkcoldplace
pfft...diana is the hottest so she gets my vote! thumbsup.gif
StarryEyedSurprize
i like Diana best but i agree with onenonly101, the idol song was written for Fantasia's voice...

Did you guys vote last night?
onenonly101
i got through only once i was mad. i like Diana but Fantasia is the one i voted for
pimpin231
QUOTE(StarryEyedSurprize @ May 26 2004, 11:55 AM)
i like Diana best but i agree with onenonly101, the idol song was written for Fantasia's voice...

Did you guys vote last night?

yup put not for daina fat a$$ tongue.gif
onenonly101
Diana is not fat, she gained weight during the competition but so had Fantasia most people llose weight under pressure not gain lik last year EVERYbody(well of course not ruben) were looking anorexic
pimpin231
QUOTE(onenonly101 @ May 26 2004, 12:16 PM)
Diana is not fat, she gained weight during the competition but so had Fantasia most people llose weight under pressure not gain lik last year EVERYbody(well of course not ruben) were looking anorexic

yeah shes is _dry.gif
grrfield
haha my TV doesnt show AMerican Idol mad.gif pinch.gif
miss-blasian
i like fantasia!
krnxpdork
QUOTE(Senorita_Babo @ May 25 2004, 12:11 AM)
they both suck, but if i must choose, fantasia, she's older, wiser and sings better.

WISER..? CHI, SHES A HIGHSCHOOL DROPOUT AND HAS A KID.! ONLY AT THE AGE OF 19 --; DIANA TOTALLY SHOULD OF WON!

`--DIANAMITE FAN~
CJ1
QUOTE(illmizzkim @ May 25 2004, 8:54 PM)
I think Jasmine is way hotter than all of them though!




biggrin.gif

Yeah, she's mad hot, but her voice just isn't good enough for American Idol. It's still pretty good though.

I also like Camile. I wanted to poke her =)

krnxpdork, try not to sound so harsh.
allen
Yay, snaps for Fantasia. *attempts to snap* Apparantely I can't snap. Anyways, I really like that 'I Believe' song. Fantasia sings it very well. :D I liked Camile also, and she has an awesome voice, except I think she just got nervous in the finals. Jasmine was just... really bad. She got the sympathy vote, that's why La Toya was voted off. -__-" Seriously, La Toya being voted off would be like... Joey ending up with Rachel on Friends! Roar. :D
xquizit
QUOTE(krnxpdork @ May 27 2004, 4:36 PM)
WISER..? CHI, SHES A HIGHSCHOOL DROPOUT AND HAS A KID.! ONLY AT THE AGE OF 19 --; DIANA TOTALLY SHOULD OF WON!

`--DIANAMITE FAN~

Hmmm... what does that have to do with anything. mad.gif
onenonly101
exactly. she obviously got her self together and is now doing what she loves and taking care of her daughter. you can't turn back the hands of time so...
ThePrincessofTKD
if that`s what you think of fantasia...I GOT SOMETHING ABOUT DIANA.

what?! gosh...people these days..

FANTASIA pretty much PWNED. i know la toya should`ve won and all...but let`s decide between the two, fantasia and diana.

what they said about diana was true. she messed up in the song. and also..her voice is just pretty much what you hear everyday. there was no difference that i heard in my ears.

fantasia has a unique voice. what entertainment needs are unique voices...when you listen to a song by an artist you never heard before..you want it to sound dfferent..not the same like everyone elses...you don`t want to COMPARE.

that`s one reason kelly clarkson won. she has a unique voice. i`m not saying justin [don`t know how to spell his last name] doesn`t have a unique voice.

but if the singer had a common voice..it`s better to make it stand out in volume and tone quality. happy.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.