i would choose lohan. i think shes a good actor AND singer

lindsay lohan. i don't like hillary duff at all.

there was a topic on this a while back sort of. but i chose lohan she is hot and way better then hilary... in my opinoin.

wasn't there a topic like this??
well i choose both...but lindsay is a way better actor i think

There was a topic on this a while ago..anyway I chose Lindsay, I hate Hilary, she gets on my nerves

"I don't give a crap" But, if you're desperate for an answer, it's lohan to me.

lindsay lohan.... she is much hotter

i choose hilary. she seems more sincere. and i think hilary is genuinely pretty while lindsay lohan is superficially hot. lindsay only looks good with her fake tan.

i hate them both personally i think lindsey lohan got breast implants and well hilary duff she jest cant sing for sh!t

Lindsay Lohan.
Unlike H.Duff, she actually has some talent.

Lindsay Lohan. No offense, but I don't think Hilary dances very well.

i said both

lindsay!!!! she is sooo beautiful and down to earth!!!!!

lindsay lohan is a friggan freckal (however you spell it) monster!@!

hilary duff is so much more hot.

i chose hilary, i think shes prettier cause lindsay seems like shes gained alot of weight and gotten kinda thick...thats prolly how she got here boobs

lindsey can act better than hilary.

lindsay is pretier than hilary. Hilary is just this little... thing...

but i dislike them both anyhow

lohan and duff....hmmm...well they're both pretty except i think lohan is prettier cause of her hair. they both have good voices even though i think lohan's is better. but duff's the one of a kind good grl that u never see n lohan is the bad grl/slut that u see everyday. but duff is greedy for quittin lizzie maguire...so i dunno....uhh....i guess both SUCK!

neither of them know how to sing.... they just get easy starts into that business because they act and hillary duff cant act either so these r the stats



Hillary Duff v.s. Lindsay Lohan

Bad: Bad:
Cant sing Cant sing
Cant act

Good: Good:
Her looks Can Act
Her Looks

So in the end Lindsay Lohan wins it for me

neither of them know how to sing.... they just get easy starts into that business because they act and hillary duff cant act either so these r the stats



Hillary Duff v.s. Lindsay Lohan

Bad: Bad:
Cant sing Cant sing
Cant act

Good: Good:
Her looks Can Act
Her Looks

So in the end Lindsay Lohan wins it for me

neither of them know how to sing.... they just get easy starts into that business because they act and hillary duff cant act either so these r the stats



Hillary Duff v.s. Lindsay Lohan

Bad:
Hillary:
Cant sing
Cant act
Lindsay:
Cant sing

Good:
Hillary:
Her looks
Lindsay:
Can Act
Her Looks

So in the end Lindsay Lohan wins it for me

i dunno .. i liek both but i would sey i liek lindsay lohan more.

i choose lohan. she dresses with style and sings good. duff sucks.

i choose lindsay lohan cuz i completly despise hilary duff. she makes me nausiated

lindsey lohan for sure -- hilary duff is lame i hate herr

I like them both~

LINDSAY.

lindsey lohan

hillary duff annoys the SH** out of me!!!!! lol

Lindsay Lohan all the way!! I absolutely can't stand Hilary. She just pisses me off. haha lolz

lohan can actually ACT...and hilary....ugh!

hmmm hillary duff is kinda hot and i dont no who the fudge lindsay or watever is

i hate it when people say someone in the entertainment business is ugly, because those people still have enough nerve to have there whole life displayed in public. even though i think hilary duff and lindsay lohan need to be a little more orignal, hey as long as something isn't forced on me i think its cool that they can actually make it the the business.

i would say lindsay lohan... but i dont know wats going on with lindsay lohan and hilary duff... it's hard to love them both cause they're maybe might be up to something... hilary duff is so sweet and would love helping the animals out there and help the sick children... and lindsay lohan... i dont know wat she did to make this world better. but she's cool... but i dont know if i want to say she's nice...cause i havent see her in reality show or anything that much...just hilary duff since i saw her show "lizzie mcguire"...heh...and also her music video "so yesterday" and "why not" i didnt see lindsay lohan that much...only in her movie "parent trap" and that was all.

I like 'em both. I think people like Lindsay more because Hilary's so squeaky clean...At least, that's the image she puts off. She is asociated with disney. Imagine if she was in a movie like Mean Girls. Bye-bye endorsements. No more Duff Stuff.

neither... both tries too hard. duff is too clean/pop, lohan is doing a hip hop album... oh the horror!!!!!

LL is hot for sure



For the record, just because hilary helps animals or whatever doesnt mean she's nice. One of my friends used to live in Texas, and went to the same school as her, and she said that hilary was extremely rude and stuck up, especially when she got the role for lizzie in lizzie mcguire. plus no one liked her. so as a person, hilary might "help animals" but probably is not any meaner than lindsay. plus hilary's the one freaking out because lindsay has bigger tits than her, seriously she needs to get over some things. the only reason why hilary's image is so squeaky clean is because she can't wear her precious water bra while wearing a bikini.

LINDSAY LOHAN! I really like how she acts n sings.... for hil well ... i dont really like her at all... but that's my opinion

lohan all the way .. i hate hilary ahh .. and im jealous cuz shes in a new movie with CHAD MICHAEL MURRAY<3 ;] lol

I'm gonna have to say Hilary Duff.

Lindsay Lohan bugs me for some reason.

i love them both. Can't choose.

LINDSAY! hilary is way too peppy & preppy.

Uh.....they both can't sing But at least Lindsay Lohan can act, so I choose her.

I dont think Lohan can sing at all!! I really dont like either one, they are both overrated..

Hilary's a goodie 2 shoes lol I hate her but LL has been goin weird lately lik she really skinny now but I still wen wit LL...

lindsey lohan is much prettier then hilary duff.

Lindsay needs a support bra and she's prettier, but otherwise, they're both untalented bitches.

both suck at singing
hilary sucks at acting

so i guess Lohan....plus i liked Mean Girls a lot so i pick her.

they both are good....but i like lindsay better....

Hilary Duff!

That's hard to choose. I choose none.
Hilary- can't sing, can't act, however, cleaner than Lindsay.
Lindsay- can't sing either, but some acting talents, being ANOREXIC?, image is getting worse for her now.