I dont like both, i hate Hilary more so i would have to choose Lindsay.

neither. not one of them.

neither. i don't like they way they sing or act.

None. They both pretty much sux.

lindsay lohan is totally effing hotter than hilary duff by ten fold.

i like lindsay better cos i have thing for ppl who dress provacatively (sp??) but i like hilary's latest cd..she sux at acting tho..well..she doesnt suck..but shes not great

I like Lindsay better..whenever Hilary acts, she always acts the same exact way but Lindsay can be different characters. I don't like that they're singing now too. It's a stupid way to get publicity.

Oh, wow. they both suck. end of story

I dislike them both.
but I have more respect for Hilary because she isn't a whore =D

Lindsay all the way cause hillary is a really bad actor she's like dirt to me

Lindsay Lohan, because I think she's more talented than Hilary. LIke she can sing, act, dance, etc... I don't think Hilary can do any of that. But Hilary have a better image than Lohan, yet I like Lohan better. And you know those designs that Hilary made, like they are so ugly! Even I can do better and I have seen designs that Hilary can never do.

I really think hilary duff cannot act or sing. I really liked lindsay til she starved herself. But yeah, shes cuter (when redheaded and not stick thin) than hilary anyday. :D

i dont like either's acting, but Hilary sings better than Lindsey, and Lindsey Lohan has a lot of boob shoots

Lindsay, I dont like Hillary at all. But I hate how Lindsay lost a lot of weight.

Omg. Lindsey Lohan! Hilary Duff has no talent AT ALL. Pssht.

Lohan All the WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY =D-

er not sure. hilary duff is hot. and lindsey lohan has nice physical features ; ) ahahahha

i dislike both but i like lindsay lohan better. i can't believe how skinny she got.. its so wrong she was prettier when she was normal weight

this may sound weird, but i hate hilary duff because her nasty fatty huge arms lmao. and i dont like her songs. eckk

linday lohan for sure
shes a good actress and vocalist
i dont care what everyone says
its like a fad to dislike famous girls or something
think about it
people always are like omg i cant stand:
paris hilton, lindsay lohan, jessica simpson, nichole richie, ect.

i dont like either of them, but if i had to choose, id say linsay because im a red head. haha.

How about neither and we call it a day. =)

Out of the two....I'd pick Hilary Duff.

Lindsay Lohan.

i hate them both..

Lindsay looks better. So.. Lindsay.

i think hilary is the better singer and is prettier, but i think lindsay is the better dancer and has better movies/videos and is the better actress. (i voted for hilary in the poll though)

I dont' especially like Hilary's singing. I mean, she sings like any regular teenaged girl and she's too perky. Hilary thinks way too much of herself. Lindsay Lohan is a far better singer and sounds like she has so much more experience, she can play the guitar (I think), has better music videos, can dance and act way better. Lindsay Lohan all the way.

I hate Hilary Duff for going into singing [she synthesizes all of her songs damn it] and I used to like Lindsay Lohan more but since L.L. dyed her hair blonde, I like neither. -_-

Yeah. Her hair looks horrible and unnatural blonde. ^ Hilary Duff is fat.

Lindsay Lohan. At least she doesn't show off, like Hilary Duff. Pfft.

i chose hilary just cause i love her.

but yeah lindsay lohan is more talented but you didnt base it on that.

hilary is ok,lindsay is just to gross to look at

Lindsay Lohan. Though her recent slimming kinda put me off her abit.

don't get me started . Lindsay Lohan. she can act and sing. not like Hilary..

neither, they are both disgusting now

there both queer ones got fake teeth the others got fake tits

lindsay lohan. =D

UHHHHHHHHHH So hard to pick. I would have said Hilary Duff in a second , because I can't STAND Lindsay Lohan.but...On the VMA's Hilary was such a ditz and a poser when she was like, ' my boyfriend joel got me into some bands i never listened to before, that i LOVE!, like morrisey, afi, the murderers (the killers!)' and that really ticked me off....so..um.. Lindsay? EHH i can't believe I said it! Lol

^LOL yeah, that was stupid of her. get a life, Hilary whore.

Hilary Duff

Lindsay Lohan! I loved her in "Mean Girls" and "The Parent Trap" movie. I bought her CD last year and it's soo good! Plus she can dance and she's not fat.

i dont like either of them.

i know, i love her cd.

i like lindsay lohan a lot better than hilary duff...i like how lindsay is consistant. her songs match her teenager views on love and how she parties...however hilary duff's new song "wake up" strikes me as odd. her image is built up on how nice and sweet she is and etc...she's never in the news about partying all over the place.

is this her comeback to lindsay's club song-ish song rumors? after all in the beginning hilary talks about how people talk sh*t about her.

lindsay lohan

i like lindsay better. she can actually act, unlike hilary.

lindsey lohan

I don't know why people hate Hilary Duff so much. I put I don't give a crap beacuse, well Lindsey is not that great of a person and Hilary seems so much nicer. Lindsey is artificial and Hilary is cute for real. They both sing the same to me and they both act just as good. So in essence I'm saying they both suck... Lol.

Neither.
I hate them both.
But if I had to choose, I'd say Lohan.
She is better than Duff.
Acting, singing, and I think dancing?
o__o;;

lol. thats what you think. unfortunately, I have a fan of Hilary in my family, and she went to her concert. she had back stage passes, and asked for an autograph.. and that, and behind the camera, she is just bitchy.

Lindsay and Hilary can be. they are like the same.
Lindsay = good dancing, and acting, singing is ok, and very beautiful.
Hilary = none. she is ok on the acting, and she looks like a duck with her veeners. =D