Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Anime or Manga?
Forums > Community Center > Interests > Anime
Pages: 1, 2
digital.fragrance
Well, which is better, Anime or Manga? I personally like the artistic form of the manga, but the animated aspect of Anime. To me, it's a pretty tough choice. Why substitute the artistry for the action.... hmmm... I think I'd have to go with Anime... since it's free on TV and I'm feeling lazy right now.
rainnydaiis
I perfer both. because manga of course is faster than the usual anime so I can just read ^^. But I like black and white once in a while. And I love anime because I just love seeing the movement and the action unlike manga where it skips ^^
islandgirl4eva
I really couldn't choose between the two. I love both. Anime adds a whole new dimension to the story, with the colors and sounds/music. However, the artwork seems to lose a bit of it's integrity. For that, I look to manga. The detail that the mangakas put into their work is astounding. I love it.
Zatanna
^ I'm with Naomi and voted both. I also want to add that sometimes manga allows you to use your imagination more - like what *you* think they'd sound like, what types of interactions off page you *don't* see, etc...
digital.fragrance
Yeah, I should have voted for both. I find that manga images do lots better with web graphics - the picture is high quality and the artistry is unrivaled.
ranniel
i like the anime because it has audio and animation and stuff. but i like the manga, cause sometimes its more updated than the manga, and portable and gives you and extended mind for reading.
F_L_I_P
I like em both sometimes the story in the anime is different from the manga but it still falls in the same plot line(or is it the other way around?). I like different view on the same thing.

-Phil-
rainnydaiis
As a anime otaku and lover I must respect both types ^^.
smrkangl
Both. It is a tough decision and i'm glad that "both" was an option :D
digital.fragrance
I really wish Anime followed the manga storyline - but then again, some of those storylines are a bit dirty.

[woot 800th post]!!!
NgocQuyen
i actually prefer anime... _smile.gif
juliar
I prefer manga. Just because I do. I haven't exactly realized why yet, though.
digital.fragrance
Hey juliar - you ought to join Anime Otakus!
leesuhhh
i like manga more... i dont know why, i guess i'm just weird like that.
Blow_Don't_SUCK
I like manga. It just has more of thte story in it and it usually lasts longer
wayne
manga. it lets your imagination explore things more.


but anime is animated... lol thats why they call it anime. hahaha so iono... i preffer manga over anime sometimes.
aicilah999
couldnt decide...
both then.
Ambuletz
Manga. I just like reading more first of all.

But anime..just gets bothersome after a while. Constantly playing the same music. It's like, you know a battle is gonna happen or something's going down whenever they play a certain music. =P

And plus they're so overly dramatic {Not that they're not dramatic in manga, but I'd rather read drama than listen to it.}; like when someone is dying, they constantly repeat their name. It's like, get on with it kthx.
AnnahhbeL
I like manga.
The illustrations are so amazing!
DemoiceDevil
I like both. Personally I like to listen and not read but manga`s are interesting. The anime and manga is different not a lot just a little so it`s like they`re own story. Some manga`s have black and white picture`s which I can learn to draw but other`s are just as colorful as the anime
marzipan
i absolutely love manga! i prefer it over anime
Paradox of Life
Manga, fo' shizzle. Anime has been so influenced by America now.
distortedMIND
QUOTE(digital.fragrance @ Mar 10 2006, 10:08 PM) *
I really wish Anime followed the manga storyline - but then again, some of those storylines are a bit dirty.

[woot 800th post]!!!


There are actually SOME anime that follow the manga's storyline. I've seen a couple, but it's out there. :DD

To answer the question, I actually prefer the anime. Even though I'm limited to what I can imagine, I still know some decent anime that will make me experience tons of emotions, even some that can make me cry. ;__;
Indiscriminate Soul
I like anime. There's the music and sound effects that you can't get from manga. Some versions of characters also look better-to me-in the animated version. For instance, I love the anime series Trigun. The manga version...not so much. I also like the animated version of Escaflowne more than the manga. With X/1999, I love the music in the animated version. I both the manga and anime version of X/1999.
Paulina
I like the manga better because it's faster to read than to watch the anime and I get mad if a voice doesn't sound right on the anime. The artwork looks better too.
Just_Dream
Definitely manga. Although I DO LOVE watching anime, manga contains all the necessary information. Plus, what if there's a blackout? What if my cable service/provider was cancelled, as well as my internet? At least my manga will still be there! Even if it does cost a lot overtime, in the long run, I think it will last longer.. :P


Plus, the artwork in mangas are far better than the graphics in anime. Just because anime is in color sweating.gif and is well.. animated, doesn't really matter to me, and neither do the voices. And man, in many dubbed animes on tv nowadays, the voices are horrible lol.

Manga all the way!
F_L_I_P
QUOTE
Definitely manga. Although I DO LOVE watching anime, manga contains all the necessary information. Plus, what if there\'s a blackout? What if my cable service/provider was cancelled, as well as my internet? At least my manga will still be there! Even if it does cost a lot overtime, in the long run, I think it will last longer.. :P


Good point!

-phil-
anheuser
i would say both.. but im really leaning over to anime _dry.gif
SarahxJoy
I like both manga and anime.

But there are a lot of times when I like anime better, 'cause it goes more into detail and the manga leaves out a lot of parts compared to the anime. Like how I can be on the seventh episode of an anime, and yet it'll be like the third issue in the manga version. Aiiee. wacko.gif
Miayako
Oh manga, most deff. Of course, Anime does tend to produce really great shows as long as it isn't based off a manga. Anime tends to ruin it, just like movies and books. happy.gif
mezeni
i like both. but i think manga delves deeper into plots,relationships, and has a better story, in contrast to anime which may cut out some key scenes that would make a scene more plausible or detailed as in manga. oh and anime seems shorter.
july-eighth
I prefer manga. I really like looking at the artwork and the extra illustrations. Plus, if an anime is based on a manga, most/some of the time it'll end at a point that it not at the end of the manga. There's also the fact that manga is less expensive, in a way. sweating.gif
StrangeMagic
Manga was the first thing i really got into, so it holds a place with in me
leopard_print
i say both, because watching you are watching anime, its like you are in the anime itself. you get that feeling when the character does something. manga is awesome too, because you get to keep the manga after you read it or something.. lol. its all cool.
Cristy
I don't think that either is really better than the other; it's just about if you prefer to read or watch. It's fun seeing the characters come to life in anime, but I like reading manga much more.
DarkImpressions
Anime.
Xoul
well, i like both. but i kinda like to watch anime more, since im lazy like that. i would read manga when im bored or when i actually feel like reading something xD
Stephire
Manga.
I always feel like I get more of the story when I read it.
aucifer
Manga of course!!!
Note
Manga's more detailed when it comes to the story in most anime. Not to mention the art's a lot better to. But the voice actors and chibi scenes make anime a whole lot better. So i donno. Depends I guess.
XRosesXAreXBlackXX
I definately prefer manga over anime.The art is usually better and from what I've seen, the manga series almost always ends up being so much more in-depth than the anime.
MyMichelle
Manga - only because I read more than I watch anime.
chibichi15
ouhhhhh...this is tough. I think both of them are equally entertaining! When I don't have a TV available, I just go to Borders or Barnes & Nobles and sit and read a stack of manga. tongue.gif
DivineFox
Even though I favor both because I tend to watch more anime than read manga.
Dreamers
Hmm... Probably manga, coz it's the absolute REAL story. no filler really... You het the ORIGINAL story... The only reason I put not sure is coz I like hearing the voices and movement of the characters in anime, but I'm absolutely in LOVE with the Hunter x Hunter Manga even though Yoshihiro hasn't released in a long time... Get well soon, Yoshihiro-sensei! I'm still praying for you!
stormbringer
I like well drawn manga, and i HATE HATE HATE english anime.. so I will have to go with , with.. manga. (and japanese anime) dude this is hard.
omgomgKATHY
I voted both cause they're both great^_____^
TriniKing22
anime is way better dan manga i think lol
F_L_I_P
Nowdays i prefer Anime over Manga. If i'm into something like BECK or Nodame Cantabile, i'd watch and be able to hear the show. Same goes for action, i'd rather watch the anime version of it. But manga's style of drawing is what i prefer more than anime.
dannyordinary
Manga..for me, i love the art more than the animated form
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.