People cried in these two movies a lot and is one of the best movies ever, so i just wanted to see which was better than the other.

You can answer based on the book if you read both of them.

Give your reason of your choice.






I pick The Notebook because of I love the old fashion setting, and i thought it had a happy ending it wasn't a sad ending for me, i liked it how they died together. I rather of the life of Allie than Jamie, and not because Jamie dies.

a walk to remember.

a walk to remember ya

I've seen both movies and have read both books...but I think "The Notebook" as a book was much better..

But as a movie, "A Walk To Remember" was better. I used to watch that movie everyday lol.

the notebook. since that was the only one i've seen :\
the book version of the notebook was much better, so yeah.

The notebook was pretty sad but i didnt really feel like crying.. and i heard a walk to remember was better so i want to see that.

Hmm, they're both sad... Yeah, The Notebook as a book was better than the movie. But, I liked the ending of how they died together. I want that to happen with my boyfriend and I.
Eh, but A Walk To Remember is kinda my boyfriend and my movie; we're planning on naming our son Landon hah.

a walk to remember.

The notebook was deffinately better
I cant stand a walk to remember

YOU FORGOT MESSAGE IN A BOTTLE!!!!

But I really liked 'The Notebook'

^I'm guessing you meant Message


And I haven't seen the entirety of either.

lol yeah I fixed it..having a bad typing day.

I watched both and I liked The Notebook better. I don't really know why, but A Walk to Remember bored me and I never got into it. I think I have to watch it again to really appreciate it.

The Notebook was awesome... I haven't seen A Walk To Remember but I read the book, and it was kinda boring to me... =/

the notebook all the way baby! i cry every time i see it..plus ryan gosling isn't too bad on the eyes ;) [COLOR=purple]

i'd have to say a walk to remember it made me cry so many times and also cuz shane west and mandy moore look really cute together hehe...but the book for a walk to remember was not as good as i expected the movie was way better

A Walk to Remember...it had a really sad ending. In the Notebook, at least they died together.

both books/movies were excellent. i think i liked a walk to remember better, though =)

i really liked "a walk to remember" but "the notebook" is really good too :D

What about Message in a Bottle?

Meh that's what I say. I liked that one.

Message in a Bottle was in 1999...Hmm, I was a bit too young to remember. A Walk To Remember had a few tracks of Switchfoot. Heh, but The Notebook made me cry a lot and that's basically my mother's life without the happy ending...Yeah, I loved The Notebok because it was a mega cry-fest with my mom. I haven't read the books, I leave that up to my mom.

I love A Walk To Remember... I don't know. It was just sweeter to me than The Notebook... or maybe, because I saw The Notebook in a room full of OLD people... and was uncomfortable to get too into the movie.

A bit too young? I was 11 or 12! Loved that movie.

walk to remember
the notebook

cried in like both of them ;)

i love that book! Movie was good too.

as for the movie choices, i think i liked a walk to remember better.

they should make a movie of his book the rescue.

The Notebook never really appealed to me, I guess I never gave it a chance. I really liked A Walk To Remember though, liked it enough to read the book afterwards.

The Notebook had a bigger punch with me!

a walk to remember...
ahh the first movie to make me cry

The Notebook.

Rachel McAdams/Ryan Gosling > Mandy Moore/Shane West

^ I like Rachel McAdams as an actress, but I liked A Walk To Remember more. They were both really sad, I was completely bawling while watching A Walk To Remember. I loveddd it! Plus, Shane West is one hottie.

A walk to remember. Oh my God!