If they know how to apply it correctly (and chose the right shades, foundation, yadda yadda) and don't cake it on and over do it, than no. I don't want to see women with thick foundation, bright red lips, and 2 tons of eyeliner. I wear make-up. I like it. It enhances my eyes and gives me confidence... but I also know when to put the stuff down.

It doesn't matter to me but if it's like 10 pounds of make up then it's bleh.

Thats nice, as the girls on this forum have no intereaction with you unless its over the screen, where they send pictures to you. You get to actually know them, without seeing what they look like before hand.
Thats interent.
What about real life?
Now, in real life, people's looks are the first thing a person see's when they meet someone new.
If your not pretty, chances are the person first meeting you is not going to see you in a romantic way unless they get to know you later on and change opinions about you to fit their growing attraction.
Looks are important.
And, when I use to have acne, no guy ever wanted to go out with me because I wasnt "pretty". All the dudes liked me as a friend, since I have a great personalty, but I wasnt attractive enough.
That all changed when I grew out of acne.
I became pretty, and well, Im suddenly thrown into a world where dudes first notice my looks, and then my personalty.
The internet is an escape place where ppl notice personalty first because you cant see the persons face unless you actually want to.

If she wears it so it looks good (without it being overdone) I think its ok but if they put too much on and it looks ugly then they shouldnt wear makeup.

The only kid of makeup I wear is black eyeliner. I like smokey eyes :)

i think natural beauty for the right place is great, and for the right person... however, not many girls can pull it off...

This makes me self consious.

no makeup for girls in my opinion. it looks like the're barbie dalls.

*dumb*

I have to question whether or not the guys who have responded actually know what they're talking about when it comes to makeup.

I really don't mind a girl wearing make-up, but too much is not nice.

Mascera(sp?) only please.

EDIT:
Or maybe its eyeliner. Whatever that black shit is that goes on your eyelidsss.

i don't mind.. but i like girls that look amazingly hawtt without make up. And if they do look good without make up, why wear it? =] I guess it's ok for dances and stuff though. But it doesn't matter haha.
Girls that wear way too much make-up is a turn off.. especially if it smells.

It really doesn't matter to me as long as they don't overdo it. I hate seeing girls with all this makeup on like they are about to be the main event at the big apple circus.

i think if she has a nice tan then she doesn't need anything on
althpugh i guess it depends on the girl

Honestly, I don`t wear make-up at all, especially not to please guys.
I don`t wear make-up, ever.

but thaaaaaaaaaat`s just me.

Well, I personally LIKE putting makeup on. I'll go all exotic and wear like, green, hotpink, purple, blue eyeshadow. Personally, If I like it, then I don't care if other people do.

Makeup is fine till it gets to a certain point where they start looking like a clown. A little is great but over doing it can be an epic fail. And please girls go lightly on the eye liner.

Some girls look fresh if they do not wear make-up.
Some look fresh if they wear a little.
and some girls need it.

It just all depends

personally I like when they wear make up it shows that they take the time to look god imo

I only have tolerance for lip gloss. If the girl thinks she needs make up to look pretty, then her self esteem doesn't meet my expectations and isn't worthy of my companionship.

Couldn't the same be said about your obsession with body building?

No. Because I don't use bodybuilding for self esteem boost. I use it for an ego boost (I only talk the shit that I can back up about myself) and for the sake of my health. My self esteem is indestructible to you pathetic weak minded, emotional humans

Just making sure you weren't being hypocritical.